Back to top

Foiling

Created by Sputnik11 Sputnik11  > 9 months ago, 3 Sep 2016
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
seanhogan
seanhogan

QLD

3424 posts

7 Sep 2016 7:41pm
After having seen both, I'm quite happy with my choice, the foil is only going to be used in sub 14 knots ..... can't see the point in spending the extra $$ just for carbon. And the alloy mast is really stiff/rigid, no flex at all.

neil pryde is going to release a foil for the average/week end sailor with an aluminium mast and g10 wings. I would expect they know what they are doing.
Sputnik11
Sputnik11

VIC

972 posts

7 Sep 2016 9:02pm
Select to expand quote
seanhogan said..
After having seen both, I'm quite happy with my choice, the foil is only going to be used in sub 14 knots ..... can't see the point in spending the extra $$ just for carbon. And the alloy mast is really stiff/rigid, no flex at all.

neil pryde is going to release a foil for the average/week end sailor with an aluminium mast and g10 wings. I would expect they know what they are doing.


Nice one. I will go with the cheaper model.
Sputnik11
Sputnik11

VIC

972 posts

8 Sep 2016 11:56am
Select to expand quote
seanhogan said..
After having seen both, I'm quite happy with my choice, the foil is only going to be used in sub 14 knots ..... can't see the point in spending the extra $$ just for carbon. And the alloy mast is really stiff/rigid, no flex at all.

neil pryde is going to release a foil for the average/week end sailor with an aluminium mast and g10 wings. I would expect they know what they are doing.


Sean - what's the extra syringe for?
RAL INN
RAL INN

SA

2896 posts

8 Sep 2016 12:20pm
I've attached my Zeeko alloy kitefoil to an old slalom board. The first time out the deck pad glue let go so waiting for some time to remedy.
The alloy foil felt stiff enough but I only foil floated from one chop top to next.
Zeeko have experimented with a carver wing but feel there has to be some extra strength added.
Zeeko use a 3 bolt alloy mast which has been fine. But there have been issues with the alloy masts/struts that use 2 bolt system.
seanhogan
seanhogan

QLD

3424 posts

8 Sep 2016 3:02pm
It's TF gel, to put on the stainless steel bolts that go into aluminium to prevent hypothetical galvanic corrosion (?) in you don't rinse your gear properly.

Like I said it's already loaded with gel, so you've got time ahead before using the extra syringe.

I asked around locally, apparently that stuff is quite expensive.
sonny2727
sonny2727

VIC

155 posts

8 Sep 2016 3:37pm
Select to expand quote
DunkO said..
These are scary times to be a snorkeller


greenleader
greenleader

QLD

5283 posts

8 Sep 2016 10:26pm
Select to expand quote
JonesySail said..
Ahh clever ! Is that even an Atom? And is that the Sling Shot Foil system (3 lengths) ... Can you make me an adaptor that at I can use the foil on both my Atom and my Kiteboard? in fact why stop there..I'll plug the thing into my SUP and give it a crack also! A Multipurpose foil, marketing genius!

keen to hear from anyone that's tried foiling on both Kite and Windsurf ...I'm thinking the Windsurf version has to be easier than kite, I'm having visions of me getting lifted on the kite as the board flips over exposing the foil !

Was that your first go GL or have you been in secret training on a remote foil Island off the coast of 'foilmauihawai' land?


First crack Jonesy and was pretty cool in sub "normal" planing conditions and yep mid size slingshot mast and pleasantly surprised how easy it was!


greenleader
greenleader

QLD

5283 posts

8 Sep 2016 10:29pm
Didn't take long though and silence took over! no kidding in 10 knots with a 6.2!



greenleader
greenleader

QLD

5283 posts

8 Sep 2016 10:35pm




JonesySail
JonesySail

QLD

1120 posts

15 Sep 2016 9:08pm
Hey GL and others that are doing it, foiling that is!

is there a particular board size that's best suited to make this happen?

So GL has used an Atom, with the Slingshot (spell check 10mtimes! SlingShi!) Neil Pryde videos they are on quite big boards.
the French Mob Horue (or whatever the brand) look to have small dedicated board, obviously you want something that floats you, but after that I'm not seeing where/why a big board is an advantage, once your up and away I would make have thought small as possible in the air? Given that you can foil a kite/wake board size doesn't seem to be an issue? Thoughts?

Fin box, aside from it being Tuttle (reg or deep) does the box and its fittings etc have to be super reinforced to handle the load of the foil, or will a normal box handle it?
scottydog
scottydog

230 posts

17 Sep 2016 2:33am
Hey thinking that I'd want to give the foiling thing a go next year, what sort of board would be right? I don't want a dedicated foiling board, thinking a nice slalom board that can also work as foiling would be the goal.

I was spying up the Isonic 107 or 117 as my option and noticed a vid using perhaps the larger version. Anyway be good to get some thoughts.

joe windsurf
joe windsurf

1482 posts

17 Sep 2016 5:48am
btw spoke to local kiter who has been @ it for some time
says he sees NO detriment in using aluminium foils !!
as you say here - the good news is less $$$
let's hope the price drops to an affordable one SOON !!!
(and i do NOT need a lesson on RIO/king = return on investment )
am just a poor "average joe" who windsurfs in a place with lotsa light wind in a SHORT summer season !!
seanhogan
seanhogan

QLD

3424 posts

17 Sep 2016 7:54am
Select to expand quote
JonesySail said..
Hey GL and others that are doing it, foiling that is!

is there a particular board size that's best suited to make this happen?

So GL has used an Atom, with the Slingshot (spell check 10mtimes! SlingShi!) Neil Pryde videos they are on quite big boards.
the French Mob Horue (or whatever the brand) look to have small dedicated board, obviously you want something that floats you, but after that I'm not seeing where/why a big board is an advantage, once your up and away I would make have thought small as possible in the air? Given that you can foil a kite/wake board size doesn't seem to be an issue? Thoughts?

Fin box, aside from it being Tuttle (reg or deep) does the box and its fittings etc have to be super reinforced to handle the load of the foil, or will a normal box handle it?



Hi Jonesy,

I've got limited experience but here's what I found out.

You do need a short large board (Hypersonic is just perfect but hard to find). Most foilers here use xfire 122, or similar. The neil pryde convertible proto was made after those specs.


Even though once in the air the width is not so important you still need it to get going. (and to uphaul before you master waterstarting with those sharp blades close to your ankles.....)

A normal fin box should handle it, provided there is no gap in the top of the fin box. I advise inserting a wedge to make sure there is no empty space between the top of the foil head and the "bottom" of the box.

90 % of the pressure from the foil is vertical (unless you hit something ) so you've got to prevent it from moving upwards in the box.
scottydog
scottydog

230 posts

17 Sep 2016 6:45am
So either Isonic 107 or 117 would work by sounds of it, though the 117 might be nicer in light potentially slogging situations!
seanhogan
seanhogan

QLD

3424 posts

17 Sep 2016 8:46am
definitely the 117
scottydog
scottydog

230 posts

17 Sep 2016 7:32am
Select to expand quote
seanhogan said..
definitely the 117


Cool..... glad you said that, plus I like the 2016 style tail look over the rounded ones on the rest of the 2017's!
greenleader
greenleader

QLD

5283 posts

17 Sep 2016 10:42pm

......................................The game changer for recreational windsurfers!


nebbian
nebbian

WA

6277 posts

17 Sep 2016 10:06pm
Select to expand quote
greenleader said..

......................................The game changer for recreational windsurfers!


www.seabreeze.com.au/images/forums/icon_smile_cool.gifhttps://www.seabreeze.com.au/images/forums/icon_smile_cool.gif' />


That looks cool. Got the STL handy? I reckon it wouldn't be impossible to print.
Chris 249
Chris 249

NSW

3531 posts

18 Sep 2016 9:50am
What do you guys think about the possibility of a foiling longboard? Obviously the extra windage and weight could be an issue and you'd need a centreboard case insert so the foil was further forward, but it could be interesting to those of us who sail inland and really, really hate schlogging.

I've foiled a Moth and a Laser briefly. Quite fun but I'm not such a huge fan I'm going to spend the sort of money for a top-end specialised foiler. To me the feeling of the board or boat slicing or planing is an enormous part of the joy of sailing.
jusavina
jusavina

QLD

1494 posts

18 Sep 2016 1:53pm
Select to expand quote
Chris 249 said..
What do you guys think about the possibility of a foiling longboard? Obviously the extra windage and weight could be an issue and you'd need a centreboard case insert so the foil was further forward, but it could be interesting to those of us who sail inland and really, really hate schlogging.

I've foiled a Moth and a Laser briefly. Quite fun but I'm not such a huge fan I'm going to spend the sort of money for a top-end specialised foiler. To me the feeling of the board or boat slicing or planing is an enormous part of the joy of sailing.


Is that what you mean?
BSN101
BSN101

WA

2378 posts

18 Sep 2016 3:02pm
Select to expand quote
Chris 249 said..
What do you guys think about the possibility of a foiling longboard? Obviously the extra windage and weight could be an issue and you'd need a centreboard case insert so the foil was further forward, but it could be interesting to those of us who sail inland and really, really hate schlogging.

I've foiled a Moth and a Laser briefly. Quite fun but I'm not such a huge fan I'm going to spend the sort of money for a top-end specialised foiler. To me the feeling of the board or boat slicing or planing is an enormous part of the joy of sailing.


I thought that with the foiling set up you only needed a board the would hold your weight and allow you to get going well enough to have the foil pop you out of the water.
A long board seems to be a counter productive idea -weight length extra foil.
You would ideally want to use the smallest board that allows you to pump onto the foil & start flying.
I love my RBs and wouldn't want to put a foil on them as they are hard enough to move around on land as they are and then looking for 2 foils, 1 special order, no thanks! Schlogg, pump then fly on something 35-60ltr over your weight thats wide.

only my thoughts. A foil is on my list.
seanhogan
seanhogan

QLD

3424 posts

24 Sep 2016 2:44pm
https://www.facebook.com/windfoilbytaaroa/?hc_ref=NEWSFEED

Benjamin Tillier this week end, long distance was cancelled for windsurfers/kiters, only the foils were allowed to start.....

On the topic of fitting a foil to a "normal" board; and after talking to a few shapers and foilers, it seems that inserting a wedge in the fin box to supress the gap at the top is the solution.
Most of the force is upwards and if you can prevent the foil from moving up in the box you should be fine (except coral bombs/floating logs and turtles)

here's what I did for my patrik 128


"inalterable" kohu wood with epoxy coating
petermac33
petermac33

WA

6415 posts

24 Sep 2016 1:12pm
With a 52cm carbon fin or bigger - believe I could get a Patrik 135 litre and a Severne Overdrive 8.6m going in 10 knots.

With the same board and sail - but with a foil - how many knots would I need to plane?
seanhogan
seanhogan

QLD

3424 posts

24 Sep 2016 3:20pm
can't say, but you'd plane in 8/10 knts with a no cam 6.5
Chris 249
Chris 249

NSW

3531 posts

24 Sep 2016 5:03pm
Select to expand quote
BSN101 said..

Chris 249 said..
What do you guys think about the possibility of a foiling longboard? Obviously the extra windage and weight could be an issue and you'd need a centreboard case insert so the foil was further forward, but it could be interesting to those of us who sail inland and really, really hate schlogging.

I've foiled a Moth and a Laser briefly. Quite fun but I'm not such a huge fan I'm going to spend the sort of money for a top-end specialised foiler. To me the feeling of the board or boat slicing or planing is an enormous part of the joy of sailing.



I thought that with the foiling set up you only needed a board the would hold your weight and allow you to get going well enough to have the foil pop you out of the water.
A long board seems to be a counter productive idea -weight length extra foil.
You would ideally want to use the smallest board that allows you to pump onto the foil & start flying.
I love my RBs and wouldn't want to put a foil on them as they are hard enough to move around on land as they are and then looking for 2 foils, 1 special order, no thanks! Schlogg, pump then fly on something 35-60ltr over your weight thats wide.

only my thoughts. A foil is on my list.


I'm not really that interested, personally, in going back and forth or in just racing in open water and a breeze. If I am BAFfing on a short board, then I quite like the feel of the board planing.

But the idea of doing something unusual and going around a course really quickly across the whole range of conditions is something that interests me. I also wonder whether the longboard may be more competitive in medium/strong winds against a shortboard, when both are foiling. The longboard won't have the usual disadvantage it has with the aspect ratio of the planing surface.

As I understand it, the Moths are going faster than FW a lot of the time, and they have an even bigger issue with windage and no weight advantage, compared to a longboard.

Moving around is one of those things that you get used to; compared to our 180kg Formula 18 cat with its overall length of about 25' from bowsprit to rudder tips when on the land, a longboard is a doddle!
Parked
Parked

NSW

169 posts

24 Sep 2016 9:33pm
Sean,

Sorry to sound confused. Does your Patrick 128 have a loose box that needs wood?

If today, it took two people ten minutes to wiggle the mast head into the box, what is the spacer for?

Before the head enters the box? or to stop "box slop" of a loose head in the box?

I apologise, I saw the bit with your lube on video, but with too much Tefgel, everything got sticky :(

I have no solution?

Cheers Ian
Imax1
Imax1

QLD

4926 posts

24 Sep 2016 10:29pm
Kinda interested , 120 kg average sailer , water starter , 9.9 out of 10 gyber , plenty of Tuttle boards , should I try ???
RAL INN
RAL INN

SA

2896 posts

25 Sep 2016 6:23am
As far as I understand, Tuttles use the tapper to seat the fin ( or strut ) into place. Once the tapper is mated to the base the only way for it to go further up or in is for the male part to squash or the female part to stretch.
So if the Tuttle box can't stretch then how can having a spacer ( that can possibly inhibit the mating process) help?
seanhogan
seanhogan

QLD

3424 posts

25 Sep 2016 8:23am

First I have to apologize for my sometimes not technical english (second language... I don't know all the terms, google gave me wedge for spacer )

The wooden spacer goes in first (obviously ) then the foil, on my Patrik I have to wiggle it a bit to get it in too.
(it even still sticks out one mm,which is fine with me)

I agree about the tapper part to prevent a normal fin from coming up in the box if over tightened, but you have to consider the extreme force of the foil in action.
It will stretch the tuttle box (it's only plastic with foam around it) if you don't prevent it from going up. We've all heard those "crack sounds" when over tightening a fin, the foil will do worse.
where's bloody Barn when you need him !!



I'm not trying to prove a point, it happened to me on the hypersonic, it went up and forward !
I ended up with the two bolts sticking out behind my foot

The local shapers told me that you also have to ensure you original box is connected to both top and bottom of the board, I only have patriks and it's the case, no idea if other brands would have "non connected" boxes. (seems strange they would)

What I did for the hypersonic (as the foil strut had made holes in the box) was to insert the foil (greased and glad wrapped), drill two holes in the deck between the bolt holes, put two straws in the bolt holes, and pour microballon epoxy in the drilled holes to fill the gap. Now it's a perfect fit and there's no way the foil can come up (without ripping the board )

Imax, of course you should try, it's such a thrilling sensation !! Plus you can then ditch all those 8.8/9.6 sails and go for a blast in 8 knts !
(but beware it's bloody scary at first !!)
Parked
Parked

NSW

169 posts

25 Sep 2016 12:07pm
Sean, thanks, that makes sense.
Loading more posts...
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site