Select to expand quote
segler said..
Gosh, Sailquik, the entire LiPo and Li-ion charging industry uses voltages to determine percent of charge. There are lots of references out there that show a quite linear curve of voltage vs %. Millions of "smart" chargers for RC (planes, boats, cars, all of it) charge and discharge Li based batteries to keep them in top shape, all based on voltage to determine percent of charge. Since Li batteries degrade if stored fully charged, these chargers all allow you to discharge to something like 50% to 70% for storage. Heck, even "smart" batteries have onboard circuitry to achieve this as well. DJI drone batteries have this.
On the other hand, lead acid batteries do not display this. You have to use current and time to determine percent of charge. The battery monitor for the house batteries in my Sprinter RV uses current and time.
OK, I am not battery expert at all, but I have had this explained to me by an electric engineer, and found the same info online in battery forums:
Quotes from "experts":
"Due to the very flat charge/discharge curves for LiFePO4 batteries it is not practical to use voltage to accurately determine the SOC. On the other hand due to their very high coulomb/current efficiency of around 99.5% you can get very accurate SOC readings by keeping track of the current going into and out of the battery."
and then this:
"The only reasonable SOC you can get from voltage is at the extremes - say > 90% and < 10%. But best life is obtained when you avoid the extremes."
So it seems that for our use in these types of devices, it might not matter much? All we mostly want to know is if it is fully charged, or very flat. Assuming most people would fully charge their device after each session and not assume a percentage of, say, 50% before a session was really half state of charge.
But if fully charging all the time if not good for best life of the battery, where does that leave us?
Or is the chemistry and characteristics of these particular small batteries different from LiFePo4?
And in fact I have been advised that the exact opposite is the case with Lead Acid/AGM batteries, and there are numerous charts online that purport to give you % state of charge estimates directly related to battery voltage. But that is not relevant for this use.