Select to expand quote
Mark _australia said..
I wonder when I can afford one? I hope the Govt will give them to poor people to save the planet.
Or realise that a new phone every year, 1/4acre flatscreens and houses with black roofs no eaves and no greenery are probably stuffing the planet way faster.
Anyywayyyyy I reckon the vid has some merit. If indeed the numbers do work like he says..e
How much do you spend on a car? We upgraded EVs and sold the old one for about $11k which is not expensive for an immaculate Nissan of its age (ten years, I think).
The typical Australian car does 12,100 km per year according to budget.direct. The typical Australian ICE car produces about 4 tons of Co2 per year according to RAC WA. Engineers Australia says that over its lifetime and including car and battery construction emission, an EV SUV creates 23% as much Co2 as an ICE SUV so let's say 1 ton of Co2 per year, ignoring the fact that EV batteries have a much more useful afterlife than ICE cars. Those stats also ignore all the EV users who charge their car normally from their home solar.
Tim Berners-Lee claims that using an i-phone through its entire lifetime, including building it, has the same Co2 emissions as 9 gallons of petrol ie 80kg of Co2. See the piece on Reboxed.com. So an i-phone does NOT create anything like as much Co2 as a car.
Statistica says that a TV uses 595kg of Co2 during its life, so let's say 50kg/year. So it's BS to even come close to comparing a TV to an ICE car.
Thesba.com.au says the typical Aussie house produces 5 tonnes of Co2 per year. CSIRO says that a quick bit of work on insulation and air gaps etc can reduce that by about 1.6 tonnes. Fitting solar reduces it by 2 tonnes.
So phones and TVs do NOT "trash the planet way faster" than running an ICE unless you reckon that 5000kg is the same as 130kg. A badly designed house emits about 25% more Co2 than an ICE but that's not really "way faster" than driving an ICE car.
So someone with a properly insulated house with solar and an EV may see those two big-ticket items produce about 2 tonnes of Co2 per year, including making the car, or less if they normally charge from their home solar. Someone with a normal house and an EV will emit about 6 tonnes, including making the car. Someone who has a normal house and an ICE will emit about 10 tonnes including making the car. Phones and TVs are basically irrelevant but the car you drive is not.