Select to expand quote
swoosh said..Interesting it didn't work out. Anything to do with volume distribution? Feels like it could do with more volume behind the mast track, but at 145L it should have plenty of volume everywhere. Wingfoiling narrow boards with feet on centreline seems fine, because you don't have that interaction with the sail and fixed mast base position. For me I also found that between winging and windfoiling, you can sail pump a lot more powerfully with the sail when windfoiling, in comparison winging you do more board pumping, because pumping the wing hard is basically like trashing a plastic bag in the air in comparison.
I had also drawn up a Kalama inspired design a while back, but never got around to getting it built, but had quite a different design philosophy. Throw up some images in case it is of any interest to anyone. I went with Kalama E3 inspired chines underneath rather than cutouts, and a scow bow type nose. I found when windfoiling I've always preferred a board with more width and outboard feet position. My goal was to get plenty of volume and width under my feet, so you can jump into straps early and pump efficiently. And it was short because I wanted to be able to fit it inside the car without having to fold seats down ?? . I think it ended up around 158cm x 65cm x 95L? Still needed to tidy up some of the surfaces and tweak the nose.
Top

Bottom

Rocker

Tail
Thank you swoosh for posting those design thoughts, the board you drafted seem interesting.
These days it seems industry has abandoned wind foiling in favor of the more convenient and easy to learn for newbies wing foiling.
so development for the freeride part has stopped.
You are right that on winging the most part of the pumping is coming from foil pumping and the sail pump is more a way to balance and coordinate while pumping with the legs.
windfoiling should take advantage from the better aero performance of the sail, even a wave sail should be better performing than a wing, though pumping the foil I feel is more difficult, the rocking effect is much lower because of the rider weight shifted to the back of the board and normally the longher fuse we use makes everything more rigid on the pich axis.
To me the canoe body is the best performing design for sub planning speeds, problem is the aspect ratio is way higher than a kalama style board. a downwinder on a sup board kalama style get's up and going because of the pumping on the foil, and narrow tail and bow of the board helkp to dig into the water (just see Blaz Muller starting from zero speed doing that). Getting flying just because reaching foil flight speed would be impossible if relying only on the low drag of the board to reach significant subplanning speeds.
For this reason, I think the route should be to develop a design which allow a more efficient pumping instead of aiming to reduce drag as the only mean to get going in light winds.
With foiling, given the so low drag when you are up on the foil vs the drag that you have on the water watever the design, the strategy need to be to try the way to get up the earliest using the foil and the sail.
Even the America's cup design is not something we may aim at, the power they get from the huge sail surface is not something we can get on a windsurf boasrd (My idea of freeriding is not getting a 12 meter sail and go foiling), so that route to me doesn't make sense either.
On your board design; I have a question if I may ask: The stern of the board has a reduced flat surface and a bottom drop shape from nose to tail, so the rails are not fat and straight but crved and tucked...in your experience when pumping the board is this not leading to the board rocking right to left istead of getting power and going straight?
Cheers
Edoardo