I was the token cripple from '04 through '07 so it's not me, think I know the guy you mean though. Mousey dreads? Pretty sure he used to work at the pub.
I reckon the right in question works best in a W-NW swell, runs down the reef better and doesn't shut down as much. Although I still prefer the the right in the background. Sick wave but fickle.
Have you ever seen the right in between the two in full flight? A rare beast that doesn't really wake up until about 8ft and then just doesn't stop.
One of my favourite haunts was further east of that pic, hard to get in to but such a good kneelo wave. And always empty.
I miss the rock. Lots