Hubie said..
I really like that explanation Bryan.
So if I am about speed, aggressive and advanced parawinging, flat bottom.
If my location doesn't have strong wind, i am just learning, or just cruising, then a rocker to get me up as quickly as possible.
I think of it less about advanced vs beginner and more about preference. There will always be a split school of thought on what board design is best and IMO there can't be a winner. I prefer flat bottoms because I like board speed takeoffs and I love unpowered touch downs that just glide and come back up smoothly. Other shapes simply aren't my style or preference.
I think that being good at any of this stuff is largely about knowing your gear, your personal preferences, and how to make it work for your style.