Select to expand quote
Gestalt said..
kill any chance of wind in a SE - tick
It has been good sailing with the Bribie Bar - inside on the flat water the wind is stronger and less gusty, and outside in the waves it is quite safe being shallow and good jumping.
I think the discussion of closing/opening the various bars, hasn't been thought through all that well.
When the bar was open at Happy Valley / Bulcock, it was pretty much off-limits to most boats as the sand moved around too much. It wasn't traversable except at the highest tides.
The speed of flow of water, was very high. I suspect the emergency-rescue folks have forgotten how often people were swept out. My partner even had a jetski rescue due to being stuck in the washing machine while sailing on some big kit.
It seems to me that the now-closed opening, would have been a good spot to have a permanent deep-water opening. It could have had proper sea-walls so that water traffic could then safely traverse (as safe as would be any bar crossing vs what we had at Bulcock). Obviously the low lying estate would still need wave-protection too.
my $0.02 ... I think the civil-works was a good achievement, the local community will have good storm protection. However, too many politicians got involved to encourage short term political-wins... vs making good long term decisions.