Please note: We are temporarily in maintenance mode, and some features, such as Buy&Sell, Forums and Messaging are temporarily offline. Back soon!

Forums > Windsurfing General

wavesailing vs kiting

Reply
Created by Spocktek > 9 months ago, 11 Jan 2013
SugarQube
WA, 490 posts
13 Jan 2013 8:54PM
Thumbs Up

Why this hasnt happend in kiting?

Well iv sort of lost connection to windsurfing and dont know how much the sports development is being driven by marketing, But kite surfing is ruled by marketing and trend.

terminal
1421 posts
13 Jan 2013 10:05PM
Thumbs Up

CJW said...
Smithy said...
*snip
As for freestyle tricks in wave sailing, this is not new, have a look at Robby Naish way back when Adam was a boy, he was the master of freestyle tricks in the waves...


Yeah this is true, freestyle has always existed in the waves, to an extent, but there is a massive difference between gybing on a wave face and riding it backwinded/toeside and the 'new school' stuff the kids are throwing down now, most of the moves have only been invented in the last 5-10 years. Don't get me wrong Robby is a legend of the sport but it's progressed so far past his skill set it's not funny. The results we see today took the new style freestyle explosion started by the likes of R.Campello etal and their decision to push it into the waves.

What I still don't understand is why this hasn't happened in kiting?


The emphasis in kite wave riding at the moment is toward waveriding strapless and moving it toward surfing.
Kauli was also moving windsurfing closer to surfing when he was developing his very small twins and quads and using smaller sails. Trying to get back into the pocket better and use the wave power more.

In terms of aerials they are landing some strapless back loops now, but there will be limits on what they can do strapless as controlling the board in the air during rotations is very difficult.

There is some strapped wave riding where they do backloops or handlepass 360's and land back on the wave face.

I think windsurfers have the best aerials at the moment and they get back into the pocket way better than kiters can.



king of the point
WA, 1836 posts
13 Jan 2013 11:31PM
Thumbs Up

Robby Naish ONLY BAD MOVE or worst move was getting involved promoting kiting.for da $$$$$
Kites have him to thank AND windsurfers well ????????????tar





The real deal and sicness



Wild late take offs in light wind..... bobbing around to slaye a monster dragon


Oh windsurfing and kiting got something in common

Hausey
NSW, 325 posts
14 Jan 2013 6:58PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
terminal said...
What I still don't understand is why this hasn't happened in kiting?




In terms of aerials they (kites) are landing some strapless back loops now, but there will be limits on what they can do strapless as controlling the board in the air during rotations is very difficult.





If you want to open your eyes and see someone doing double back loops strapless and massive punts on a kiteboard take a look at this! No windsurfer in the world could make 25 knots onshore look this fun, and he's only been kiting 3 years.

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Kitesurfing/General/kite-wave-byron/


Robby Naish saw the future when he got into kiteboarding :)


CJW
NSW, 1731 posts
14 Jan 2013 7:28PM
Thumbs Up

Hausey said...

No windsurfer in the world could make 25 knots onshore look this fun, and he's only been kiting 3 years.



Challenge accepted

kpb
QLD, 239 posts
14 Jan 2013 7:11PM
Thumbs Up

Check out Kai Lenny 4 in 1 now this guy knows how to do it all.Seen videos of him Kiting,windsurfing,sup,tow in and paddle surf jaws.When its all said n done just get out there n have fun...thats my thoughts

aus301
QLD, 2039 posts
14 Jan 2013 7:22PM
Thumbs Up

Hausey said...

If you want to open your eyes and see someone doing double back loops strapless and massive punts on a kiteboard take a look at this! No windsurfer in the world could make 25 knots onshore look this fun, and he's only been kiting 3 years.

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Kitesurfing/General/kite-wave-byron/


Robby Naish saw the future when he got into kiteboarding :)



Some pretty interesting comments here... to me that looked a little impressive but not as much fun as I would have windsurfing the same conditions, what you see as fun is defined by only you, and you would probably see that no windsurfing will ever look as fun as kitesurfing, just as the opposite is true for many of us pole surfers.

Sure Robby did see a future when he branched into kitesurfing, a future for his company, a future for another way to enjoy the ocean etc. Interesting how he never buys into these sort of arguments, instead choosing to ride anything he can and enjoy the ocean many different ways.

Kites aren't lame, nor are windsurfers. Lame is having a pissing contest about who is having more fun when at the end of the day I bet my smile is just as big as yours after a good session, and that's all that counts.

Hausey
NSW, 325 posts
14 Jan 2013 9:37PM
Thumbs Up

CJW said...
Hausey said...

No windsurfer in the world could make 25 knots onshore look this fun, and he's only been kiting 3 years.



Challenge accepted




Ok you got me this time, that guy Koster is a super freak!

That was an incredibly diverse display of moves....



But have a look at this young Australian, now kite world wave champ!

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Kitesurfing/General/Keahi-de-Aboitiz-Hawaii-Sessions-video/

terminal
1421 posts
14 Jan 2013 7:05PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Hausey said...
terminal said...
What I still don't understand is why this hasn't happened in kiting?


In terms of aerials they (kites) are landing some strapless back loops now, but there will be limits on what they can do strapless as controlling the board in the air during rotations is very difficult.



If you want to open your eyes and see someone doing double back loops strapless and massive punts on a kiteboard take a look at this! No windsurfer in the world could make 25 knots onshore look this fun, and he's only been kiting 3 years.

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Kitesurfing/General/kite-wave-byron/

Robby Naish saw the future when he got into kiteboarding :)



The way that appeared, it looked like you were deliberately misquoting me, but it looks like it may have been an accident due to the way quotes work.

I was talking about landing a backloop strapless without holding the board and landing back on the same wave. I haven't seen a kiter do the double back loop and land back on the same wave yet.

I'm happy to acknowledge the great progress kiters have made in strapless riding - its so good it looks like magic is keeping the board on in some of the aerials, and they can get tubed, switch stance etc.
Windsurfers still havent got tubed yet.

In onshore wind kiting and riding waves is better than windsurf wave riding in onshore.
In cross-off, the bigger and better the waves are, the more circumstances swing in favour of windsurfing.
It may well be that kiters will find a way to overcome the cross-off wind disadvantage - I hope they do.
I'm not interested in a serious way in the comparison between windsurfing and kiting but it does make for a bit of fun banter between the two. As said before different people enjoy different things, or the same things and whatever you get the most fun from wins.

Hausey
NSW, 325 posts
14 Jan 2013 10:12PM
Thumbs Up

aus301 said...
Hausey said...

If you want to open your eyes and see someone doing double back loops strapless and massive punts on a kiteboard take a look at this! No windsurfer in the world could make 25 knots onshore look this fun, and he's only been kiting 3 years.

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Kitesurfing/General/kite-wave-byron/


Robby Naish saw the future when he got into kiteboarding :)



Some pretty interesting comments here... to me that looked a little impressive but not as much fun as I would have windsurfing the same conditions, what you see as fun is defined by only you, and you would probably see that no windsurfing will ever look as fun as kitesurfing, just as the opposite is true for many of us pole surfers.

Sure Robby did see a future when he branched into kitesurfing, a future for his company, a future for another way to enjoy the ocean etc. Interesting how he never buys into these sort of arguments, instead choosing to ride anything he can and enjoy the ocean many different ways.

Kites aren't lame, nor are windsurfers. Lame is having a pissing contest about who is having more fun when at the end of the day I bet my smile is just as big as yours after a good session, and that's all that counts.


Yeh true, good points; it's all about fun at the end of the day, and sometimes that might be a newby getting up and going, or catching their first wave or whatever - they might be more stoked than anyone!

It's interesting that both Naish and Cabrinha are both big names in kiting and were both at the top in windsurfing. They both would have been stoked by kiting and the potential they saw with it.

I remember watching them both at Diamond Head back in 87 and 88 on a few big days and they were so much better than anyone else on that tack. Cabrinha was super smooth and really surfed the wave really well and I think invented the back loop. Naish was really versatile, more radical and tore the place to shreds.

I used to think kiting was crap; used to laugh at Laird Hamilton trying to do it in Hawaii in 93/94, and it was only when I watched a video of Naish at Gnarloo on a kite in around 2002 that I realised I was being judgemental - I windsurfed from 1979 to 2003, and have kited since!

They are both awesome sports and this post should be locked as it's no vs. It's a draw, anyone who enjoys either will know!

Did you see this link - kiting looks pretty cool don't you reckon?

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Kitesurfing/General/Keahi-de-Aboitiz-Hawaii-Sessions-video/

EB
SA, 492 posts
14 Jan 2013 10:41PM
Thumbs Up

Only comment that comes to mind regarding the original video is that I've always appreciated Jason Polakows Commitment and style in big waves. He has been my favourite poley way before kiting was thought of. Maybe when Ben Wilson has been charging the big ones as long as Jason has and the sport progresses like windsurfing has then maybe people will have different opinions.

IMHO I think that big wave kiting needs straps to help with the extra leverage required similar to Tow in surfing and Wavesailing.

Good luck too those that wish to convince the other there sport is better. What ever happened to having fun without worrying what others think.

stehsegler
WA, 3557 posts
14 Jan 2013 8:23PM
Thumbs Up

This thread is so pointless...

CJW
NSW, 1731 posts
14 Jan 2013 11:24PM
Thumbs Up

Hausey said...
But have a look at this young Australian, now kite world wave champ!

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Kitesurfing/General/Keahi-de-Aboitiz-Hawaii-Sessions-video/



Dude shreds, that's more like it!! Still not old on the strapless thing, personally I think you could go more diverse/radical with straps, but I guess you have to make it hard somehow right ;p

End of the day as said above, it's all about having fun, everyone down my way gets along really well...although there's been more windsurfers at the beach than kiters lately...which is odd haha. I've just invested to much time in windsurfing getting to the level that i'm at now to give it away

Smithy
VIC, 859 posts
15 Jan 2013 1:48PM
Thumbs Up

The interesting thing about this thread is that it started as a comparison between two sports with points of view being provided by participants of each about the validity of the other. There has been all sought of comments about strapped v unstrapped, wind direction, aerial prowess etc.

The simple fact is that these are 2 different sports and unless you participate at a competent level in both you will never really appreciate the differences and the degrees of difficulty of what you are seeing. A maneuver in one does not translate directly to the other. It is a bit like me as a windsurfer and kite boarder making comments on SUPing in surf, I know what I think looks hard or radical but really I don't have a clue...

As many have said in this thread, it's all about what is fun to each of us as individuals and what is radical for me to be doing will be mowing the lawn for someone else. At the end of the day a level of respect for all of these sports is all we should ask for (even SUPing...)

aus301
QLD, 2039 posts
15 Jan 2013 1:09PM
Thumbs Up

Hausey said...

Did you see this link - kiting looks pretty cool don't you reckon?

www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Kitesurfing/General/Keahi-de-Aboitiz-Hawaii-Sessions-video/


Yeah I had seen that one, I think I may have even referenced Keahi in my first reply to this thread. The kid is a freak!!! I have had the opporunity to be out with him SUP surfing a few times and he just rips on anything board related.

hamburglar
ACT, 2174 posts
15 Jan 2013 2:35PM
Thumbs Up

"Wavesailing v kiting "
Discussing it in the windsurfing forum??

Kind of like "rug making v Harley repair" in
The rug makers forum

No bias there

evlPanda
NSW, 9207 posts
15 Jan 2013 4:00PM
Thumbs Up

kpb said...
Check out Kai Lenny 4 in 1 now this guy knows how to do it all.Seen videos of him Kiting,windsurfing,sup,tow in and paddle surf jaws.When its all said n done just get out there n have fun...thats my thoughts



This whole thread is mostly "My superhero is better than your superhero".

I can't sail anything like anyone in any of these videos, and never will.

dusta
WA, 2940 posts
15 Jan 2013 3:39PM
Thumbs Up

Smithy said...
The interesting thing about this thread is that it started as a comparison between two sports


this thread was started by a windsurfer with bad grammar who was looking to start a flame war between windsurfers and kitesurfers .

No sport is better than the other . Who gives a fark what kind of activity you do on the water as long as you love it and you come back into shore with a smile on your dial .

Spocktek
WA, 281 posts
15 Jan 2013 7:22PM
Thumbs Up

^^^ I reckon your guilty of slagging the opposition on here also.
Do I have to pay a fine to the 'grammar police'? (or is it ?')
Anyway the point I was getting at was 'wavesailing Vs kiting', in perfect conditions. Not what's more fun, or who gets the most chicks, or to stir the pot.
I had my first crack at kiting this season and had sick fun, and I'll do it again, but not in waves.
That is all.

spot1
WA, 1588 posts
15 Jan 2013 8:36PM
Thumbs Up


this is 2010


2 weeks ago

good rider hey

Spocktek
WA, 281 posts
15 Jan 2013 9:04PM
Thumbs Up

'Dude, can I borrow ya pump?'
Ha ha just joking that was cool!

PhilSWR
NSW, 1104 posts
16 Jan 2013 12:38AM
Thumbs Up

spot1 said...

this is 2010


2 weeks ago

good rider hey


Gotta admit, I certainly enjoyed watching that. Pretty sweet surfing skills- good power, speed and style. Cheers for sharing.

busterwa
3782 posts
15 Jan 2013 11:47PM
Thumbs Up

Typical skillless tbagger grade 1 primary school Riding down the line backside.ffs get some skill. Clearly this knob head cant switch Hasn't learn t pole surfing and shouldn't be riding waves, he is a danger to himself and the people who have to rescue him.

You mabe able to catch big waves on your tbag but clearly this video shows "he cant rock a show like that" ! or ride correctly.
"Ameture" vs "professional"

Polakow not many if any??? You kitesurfers are dreaming if you think you can out do him?!!!!



Post all the kite-surfing videos you want Hes in another league of technical down the line big wave wave-sailing.

terminal
1421 posts
15 Jan 2013 11:53PM
Thumbs Up

The kite waveriding strapless has progressed a lot on the last few years and its still progressing fast, which is good to see.

This is 3 years ago, but it shows kiters can squeeze a lot out of shorebreak waves in not a lot of space.

busterwa
3782 posts
16 Jan 2013 12:17AM
Thumbs Up


pro Kite-surfers wouldn't even get close to this guys talent and footwork down the line!!! That video just shows how Poxy big wave kite-surfing really is.

sboardcrazy
NSW, 8292 posts
16 Jan 2013 11:56AM
Thumbs Up

busterwa said...

pro Kite-surfers wouldn't even get close to this guys talent and footwork down the line!!! That video just shows how Poxy big wave kite-surfing really is.


F.. about 5 min 01 there's a jet ski in the tube that gets munched!

Sailhack
VIC, 5000 posts
16 Jan 2013 1:35PM
Thumbs Up

evlPanda said...

This whole thread is mostly "My superhero is better than your superhero".

I can't sail anything like anyone in any of these videos, and never will.


Agree...as a poley, I hadn't viewed many of these kiting vids, and although I agree that the windsurfer smashes the kiter on that 1st vid, the kiting vids posted are great! That Keahi one is exceptional - that kid rips!

As for me, well I'll stick with my poling as I rarely get enough time to do that, along with dabbling in SUPing, MTBing & fishing. As for inspiration - the best thing about these discussions is that all these great vids get lobbed on one thread (w/surfing, kiting etc.) - keep posting vids showing skills & great locations & I'll be happy.

hardie
WA, 4129 posts
16 Jan 2013 10:44AM
Thumbs Up

I've lways felt that baton twirling within rhythmic gymnastics was the highest end of radical sports? Maybe I'm just outa da loop on whats cool

Zed
WA, 1274 posts
16 Jan 2013 11:31AM
Thumbs Up

I mostly poley dance or whatever you call it, but recently got into kiting. Good for lighter days or when I'm down south (albany area) it's better for kiting. So I'm not really biased, I like both sports. But really when it comes to riding waves, a windsurfer will generally always be a better thing to have than a kite, unless it's sloppy & onshore, then a kite would be preferable.

sboardcrazy
NSW, 8292 posts
16 Jan 2013 4:43PM
Thumbs Up

How does Keahi keep the board with him in midair without straps???



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"wavesailing vs kiting" started by Spocktek