I know about one local windsurfer who has
almost given up on foiling. She was an early adapter, and was sold gear that was adequate for an expert foiler in good conditions, but impossible to learn on. The company eventually corrected this partially, but she still has a small front wing that requires 15 mph if you know what you're doing. Hard to learn on.
I have seen others who were having such a hard time that they looked ready to give up - they certainly had not reached the "fun" stage. Usually, the cause was pretty obvious - mix and match gear that was unbalanced. Not having the foil at the right place, or having too small a board, can make foiling amazingly different. That still happens to me every now and then when I try different settings or boards.
Then there is isobars, famous on the US forum, who eventually gave up. In his case, the primary cause for his problems was impaired balance. Sub-optimal conditions probably contributed.
Select to expand quote
duzzi said..
After almost two years and more than a dozen tries I am still struggling with an absurdly limited range of operation and short, when not existent, foiling runs. I spend most of my time slogging.
About twenty tries of more than a year sounds like another recipe for failure, especially in sub-optimal conditions. It takes about 10 sessions before the adjustments become automatic, and these 10 sessions need to be reasonably close together (e.g. one summer), with decent conditions in at least some of them. Space the sessions too far apart, and your body never learns what it needs to learn. I've seen the exact opposite with the local "wing girl". The first sessions were a really hard fight, with very little success. But she persisted and got in 20 sessions in a month, and now gets compliments from random kiters, and has been asked if she teaches. Foiling through jibes has become a trivial thing for her. Conditions here are decent for winging, but by no means perfect. The huge range of the wing (currently 14 - 30 mph averages with gusts in the high 30s) helped to get that many sessions in.
The "absurdly limited range of operation" indicates that your setup may not be balanced correctly. The front wing may be too far forward or too far back, or the board you're using may make learning much harder than necessary. Sometimes, even moving the mast base a couple of cm can have a suprisingly large impact. Perhaps try to get an experienced foiler to try your gear and get some feedback.
If things are adjusted correctly, the wind range of a foil is quite nice. I can usually foil comfortably on one sail where I'd use 2-3 sail sizes when windsurfing. Yesterday's range, for example, was 12 - 28 mph, and there were maybe 2 minutes in the 2 hour session where I was waiting for a gust. Can't wait to get a wing, though, because their wind range is even larger.