Select to expand quote
cbulota said..
Gorgo, you would be correct if everyone was on 10m kites in 15 knots of wind, but that's not always the case is it? Pushing the bar out in when you fail to self-land hooked in won't make much difference in strong wind (20 knots+) with a large kite when the kite hits the power zone.
...
Only if you stand there like a sack of potatoes with the bar pulled in and let the kite rocket straight up. That is only going to happen if you dig your feet in and fight the power but provide no control inputs. Line tension + airspeed + steep angle of attack = Power
The simple act of pushing out the bar and running towards the kite will depower almost any kite to a manageable level. Standing there with your feet dug in and the bar pulled in creates a huge boost of power which usually results in a big sandy face plant ... if you're lucky.
There's plenty of things you can do.
You can step in towards the kite and ease the tension on the lines reducing the power to the kite.
You can let it stabilise nose down and keep it down then work individual lines to park the downed kite (or even carefully ease the kite onto the safety system).
You can steer the kite back to the edge of the window and try again.
You can strategically release to the primary safety system (ie not just blindly dump everything).
The size of the kite and the amount of wind doesn't make all that much difference. If you're in powered up conditions and let the kite go and do nothing about it then you're risking trouble. If you have practiced and practiced and have current skills then most things are easily managed or avoided before they become a problem.
PS My personal hobby horse is the dogma of you do A,B,C and the result is D. (ie learning by rote because that was how I was taught.) The problem with that is when something different happens, as it will, you can't deal with it.
It is far, far better to spend the time to practice stuff and understand how the gear works and why it behaves the way it does, then react in appropriate ways. That way you can deal with any problem that presents itself.