Right and wrong. The main reason for surfboard foils is to distribute strength in the board to where it is needed and save weight where it's not. Other effects like a flexier tail, more floatation under the chest can be achieved too.
The main reason for pearling is not enough rocker mainly in the nose. Bogging is the opposite too much rocker mainly in the tail.
Thin tails have less hold than thick ones. You wouldn't be able to tell much from one tail to the next because of the fins. This is the tail of one the boards with the most tail/rail hold I have ridden. The concave certainly helps too.
The overall driving factor in how a board rides is its fins and their placement. Take the fins off this and it'll ride much like a skim board. Anyone that has ridden both will tell you they are nothing alike.
Its counter to the no/low volume argument, but a thicker board with the right rail shape will have better hold than any thinner one.
Perhaps that is why people cling to thicker boards. They are easier to ride.