Foetal Alchohol Syndrome - Australias worst secret

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
japie
japie
NSW
7146 posts
NSW, 7146 posts
6 Aug 2010 12:07am
If you are a believer that it is OK to have a few alcoholic drinks when pregnant you are running a serious risk of giving birth to a child who is misdiagnosed with ADHD or pervasive learning disorder and making your life a misery for the next thirty years.

When I first became aware of this problem in society at the time in the US gaols (2000) 40% were said to be there as a result of their mothers drinking when pregnant. Social workers had a saying for it: the boys get locked up, the girls get knocked up.

The alcohol industry here has knowingly not followed some precedents from the United States and put warning labels on bottles and it is quite tragic and turns my stomach when I see a visibly pregnant woman drinking.

Unfortunately most female party goers do not realize they are pregnant for six weeks by which case they are behind the eight ball even if they stop drinking immediately as most damage is done when the fetus is in embryonic stage.

This has catastrophic results in disadvantaged groups, particularly aborigines but is not rare among educated but uninformed people. I know for a fact that the Queensland governments recommendation is that two standard drinks a day is RECOMMENDED!!!!!!!!! WTF?????

If it is okay for a daily drinker to have two then how many are not going to do any harm after a few, then a few more!!!

If you don't believe it do some research. I speak from close knowledge and it ain't nice!

It may also go some way toward answering why it is that some kids you know just cannot behave.

The alchohol industry has a huge hold on a lid just waiting to blow. Tobacco is not good for mums but it does not result in brain damage (that I know of anyway).
dirtyharry
dirtyharry
WA
444 posts
WA, 444 posts
6 Aug 2010 8:30am
japie said...

If you are a believer that it is OK to have a few alcoholic drinks when pregnant you are running a serious risk of giving birth to a child who is misdiagnosed with ADHD or pervasive learning disorder and making your life a misery for the next thirty years.



That sounds a bit sensationalist and over the top.

japie said...
When I first became aware of this problem in society at the time in the US gaols (2000) 40% were said to be there as a result of their mothers drinking when pregnant. Social workers had a saying for it: the boys get locked up, the girls get knocked up.


Rather than some sort of direct chemical reaction to alcohol this probably also had something to do with the fact that kids who grow up in a house where the mother drinks heavily are also less likely get good nutrition, discipline, social development, health care etc. and more likely to suffer from various forms of abuse.

japie said...
The alcohol industry here has knowingly not followed some precedents from the United States and put warning labels on bottles and it is quite tragic and turns my stomach when I see a visibly pregnant woman drinking.

My missus had a glass of wine occasionally - I would be pretty disappointed to think that someone who witnessed her doing this judged her for it (although I would get a mild sense of satisfaction from the thought that they were so upset their stomach was turning).

japie said...
Unfortunately most female party goers do not realize they are pregnant for six weeks by which case they are behind the eight ball even if they stop drinking immediately as most damage is done when the fetus is in embryonic stage.


I'd have thought that a lot of women wouldn't know they're pregnant for the 1st 6 weeks, not just the party goers. Alcohol is just 1 of a number of substances and activities that women should probably avoid if their pregnant or trying to get pregnant - short answer is to plan pregnancies wherever possible!

japie said...
This has catastrophic results in disadvantaged groups, particularly aborigines but is not rare among educated but uninformed people. I know for a fact that the Queensland governments recommendation is that two standard drinks a day is RECOMMENDED!!!!!!!!! WTF?????

That is a bit strange. Are you sure they recommend 2 standard drinks, rather than recommending not more than 2 standard drinks?

japie said...
If it is okay for a daily drinker to have two then how many are not going to do any harm after a few, then a few more!!!

If you don't believe it do some research. I speak from close knowledge and it ain't nice!

It may also go some way toward answering why it is that some kids you know just cannot behave.

The alchohol industry has a huge hold on a lid just waiting to blow. Tobacco is not good for mums but it does not result in brain damage (that I know of anyway).


Good intentions mate, but I think that you've drawn some pretty long bows and that spreading a "drinking alcohol while pregnant is evil and anyone doing so should be looked down upon" message like you appear to be doing is a bit of overkill.
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
6 Aug 2010 11:10am
Japie is not exagerating.

Wifey is a paediatric nurse and sees these cases on a daily basis.

The bubs/kids that come from disadvantaged and dodgy backgrounds are easier to spot but it is a syndrome that is truly widespread accross the spectrum as Ozzies love a bit of nectar. Kids from better backgrounds usually have better schooling,tutors/families to help overcome the hurdles, but the hurdles needn't be there.

Up to a decade ago having a couple of drinks during pregnancy was thought no harm at all, hell even getting shellacked a few times in the 9 months was thought to do little harm. 100% wrong.

All the research shows that even a very small amount of alchohol during pregnancy has significant affects. These affects are life long.

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fetal_alcohol_syndrome

embryology.med.unsw.edu.au/Defect/page5a.htm


As Japie says unfortunately a lot of damage is done by women who don't evenb realise they are preggo at the time. Tragic.

Although I - in the great Oz tradition - love a bit of sauce, wifey has never been a drinker. At times socially I have thought it a pain in the butt, these days I mostly admire her for it, and am sooo thankful that she didn't drink regularly/heavily before, during or after the pregnancy.

Who out there thinks a preggo mum smoking is ok? Then why would introducing alchohol to the babies blood system/intake be ok? Sorry but in this day and age - if you have a bump and suck down the suds - you probably deserve the scorn afforded to preggo women who suck on tar.

Wifey has a friend I find extremely annoying and downright ignorant. She is one of the most opinionated but least informed people I have ever met. Having also met her family and knowing her mum and dad's love of the sauce (and they do LOVE it) without doubt the daughter is a FAS kid. Her sister, the same. They are around 40 and were products of a differant era. They are both from affluent backgrounds and their parents have always lived it up - BIG. The offspring are damaged I am sure of it (there are several indicators including physical).

It is fortunate that most preggo women have their taste buds turned upside down during preggo and former delights like coffee, wine etc suddenly become unappealing. Probably nature's way of stearing away from trouble.

10-20 yrs from now we will probably look back on generations that didn't adhere to zero grog during pregnancy/breast feeding in the same way we scoff at doctors doing adds for ciggies and the love Oz once had for asbestos.
japie
japie
NSW
7146 posts
NSW, 7146 posts
6 Aug 2010 2:13pm
This post was prompted by my house mates car being stolen by two kids, 13&15, form Stockton and driven at speeds of up to 150k's per hour up to Muswellbrook where the coppers eventually spiked the road and arrested them.

Their old man has been in contact and told us the story. He cannot do anything with them.

I have been there and done that. I know what the cause was in my case and it ****s me to tears that ten years later the alchohol industry STILL holds power over logic.

I am not exaggerating. It is quite, quite tragic.
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
6 Aug 2010 12:21pm
Ozzies (and we aren't alone in this) remain blissfully unaware of the huge damge alchohol does to ourselves, our society and our future.

As I said I enjoy a few bevvies and occasionally wearing a lampshade and dancing like Peter Garret but (unlike the big media whipping boys; smack, pills, speed and even ciggies) no-one want to face up to the huge financial and widespread costs that a saturation of alchohol culture does.

Everything in moderation.

Good post Japie.

landyacht
landyacht
WA
5921 posts
WA, 5921 posts
6 Aug 2010 8:24pm
my wife works with these people all the time , and health workers are starting to recognise the second and third generation babies, and connections to inability to learn . It seems to me like another one of those conditions that seems to feed on itself
j murray
j murray
SA
947 posts
SA, 947 posts
7 Aug 2010 10:37am

The women are only part of the equation,......Us boozed blokes,

appendages swollen with illicit drugs and alkeyhole pressuring the

ladies for a game of hide the sausage after a party. We contribute

big problems in the egg factory.

To be born as a result of one coupling such as this, is less than a

great start to life.

No one can select their Parents. Its a game of chance , some make it

others don't. All fetuses deserve an even start to life...or abort.
RPM
RPM
WA
1549 posts
RPM RPM
WA, 1549 posts
7 Aug 2010 10:33am
IMO obviously boredom has set in due to lack of wind. I thought this forum was related to the water/wind?

Zabongi
Zabongi
NSW
40 posts
NSW, 40 posts
7 Aug 2010 3:15pm
So instead of :
a) making his kids take personal responsibility for stealing a car and endangering other peoples lives, or
b) taking the responsibility for his children's actions himself

he chooses

c) blame someone else

The worst part is the kids will think that it doesn't matter what they do in life, it's never going to be their fault.

maxm
maxm
NSW
864 posts
NSW, 864 posts
7 Aug 2010 3:18pm
... and I find it hard to believe given the experience in Europe where it is normal for men and women (preggie or not) to consume wine in moderation with most meals. The Italian and French seem pretty normal to me. OK, maybe not sooo much the French.
poor relative
poor relative
WA
9106 posts
WA, 9106 posts
7 Aug 2010 4:40pm
I worry when bad behaviour is medicalised.
Certianly there are probably circumstances that permit the 'unsoundness of mind' defence but i believe they are rare.

Bad behaviour is exactly that - bad behaviour - and kids who know no boundaries or have never experienced consequences of their actions are more prone to acting out

Kids need stability, security, boundaries, rules and consequences not fkn dexamphetamines or medical diagnosis for bad behaviour

getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
7 Aug 2010 5:28pm
I don't think bad behaviour is trying to be passed off as 'new medical condition of the year'.

This is a recognised syndrome just as 'Downs'and many other differant syndromes mean there are classic and recognised indicators. Basically we are talking mild to severe brain damage to many aspects of the brain and classic physical characteristics.

Yes - there is a high incidence among 'difficult 'members of society. That doesn't mean it is being used as a defence (generally) to get crims of a charge, but it is the results of the syndrome - and the affect is has on the baby, that one day becomes a 'problem' for everyone - staring us in the face.





He he - yeh some wind would be good.
evlPanda
evlPanda
NSW
9207 posts
NSW, 9207 posts
7 Aug 2010 7:32pm
Japie is 100% correct m***********s!

"Fetal alcohol exposure is the leading known cause of mental retardation in the Western world.In the United States and Europe the FAS prevalence rate is estimated to be nearly one in every 100 live births."

I thought this was common knowledge nowadays? Look, it's even on the internet now:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fetal_alcohol_syndrome

Japie said...the alchohol industry STILL holds power over logic.


Does it or what? And how about cigarettes? Statistically marijuana is far, far safer than alcohol, yet it is still illegal (except here in SA?). Now I'm in no way saying it is completely safe, but what I'm saying is that people seem so dogmatically stuck on valuing opinion over fact.

It's funny, I've got relatives that would freak if they saw me smoking a quiet spliff in Australia, but photos of us doing same in Amsterdam are funny.

I digress, sorry. You wouldn't get your toddler drunk, so why would you get your unborn baby drunk?



Skid
Skid
QLD
1499 posts
QLD, 1499 posts
7 Aug 2010 8:26pm
^^ Not to play down the damage that can be done to an unborn child by all drugs. But I have to agree with what PR said, plus add that diet can have an affect on a childs behaviour. Know that a few simple diet changes helped change my sons' behaviour. Removed some of the crudd from his diet, replaced that with green & orange vegies and tamtrums dropped 90%

Btw, reading this reminds me... When my (now ex) wife was pregnant with our second son, she insisted of drinking lots of coffee
From an early age our son would seek out coffee, so much so that 'coffee' was one of his earliest words. Try explaining to a mother, that iced coffee is NOT an appropriate drink to give a 2 year old
Fast forward 8 years and 1 divorce and then explain to the same mother that redbull is NOT an appropriate drink to give a 10 year old
4 years later he still seeks out caffeine.

His mother layed off the coffee when pregnant with his brothers and neither of them have ever shown any liking or interest for coffee.

Japie, I don't mean to hijack your thread. Thanks for sharing your thoughts/experience.
maxm
maxm
NSW
864 posts
NSW, 864 posts
7 Aug 2010 9:37pm
getfunky said...

All the research shows that even a very small amount of alchohol during pregnancy has significant affects. These affects are life long.


evlPanda said...

I digress, sorry. You wouldn't get your toddler drunk, so why would you get your unborn baby drunk?


I think there is a world of difference between a "small amount of alcohol" and getting sh!tfaced. I think what we have here is an example of intensification. We get indications that pregnant women getting sh!tfaced is bad and then just expand that to say that all alcohol during pregnancy is bad. I say "beat-up".

Reminds me of the other beat-up - that saturated fats are bad because they produce high cholesterol leading to coronary heat disease. OK... except that the French eat incredible quantities of butter. Some parts of France, food is routinely fried in duck fat and they use lots of butter and cream (HUGE saturated fat content). Result? A population with a very low incidence of coronary heart disease.

WTF?

The medicos call that "the French paradox". Paradox my hairy backside! Obviously they don't properly understand what is going on. I'll stick to the population studies as represented by the European experience thanks.

japie said

When I first became aware of this problem in society at the time in the US gaols (2000) 40% were said to be there as a result of their mothers drinking when pregnant.


I think 40% were there because they probably committed a crime.
Zabongi
Zabongi
NSW
40 posts
NSW, 40 posts
7 Aug 2010 10:13pm
maxm said...
evlPanda said...

I digress, sorry. You wouldn't get your toddler drunk, so why would you get your unborn baby drunk?


I think there is a world of difference between a "small amount of alcohol" and getting sh!tfaced.


+1

The wikipedia link says
FAS...develops in some unborn babies when the mother drinks excessive alcohol during pregnancy.


I wouldn't judge a mother for having the odd drink during pregnancy.

getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
7 Aug 2010 10:58pm
or the odd ciggy then?
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
7 Aug 2010 10:58pm
or the odd scoob?
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
7 Aug 2010 10:59pm
or the odd line?
evlPanda
evlPanda
NSW
9207 posts
NSW, 9207 posts
8 Aug 2010 4:11pm
myusernam
myusernam
QLD
6158 posts
QLD, 6158 posts
8 Aug 2010 6:29pm
i worked with a bogan chick that said the only thing that cured her morning sickness were 'buckets'

stupid bogan feral
maxm
maxm
NSW
864 posts
NSW, 864 posts
8 Aug 2010 9:24pm
getfunky said...

or the odd ciggy then?


getfunky said...

or the odd scoob?


getfunky said...

or the odd line?


GF, none of those are the same as one or two drinks and you know it. You cheapen your argument just by raising them. For the record - no, I don't endorse anyone having the odd ciggy, scoob and certainly not a line, whether they're male or female, pregnant or not. But neither am I endorsing putting a huge guilt trip on a young pregnant woman just because she likes a glass of wine occasionally.
myusernam
myusernam
QLD
6158 posts
QLD, 6158 posts
8 Aug 2010 10:41pm
maxm said...

getfunky said...

or the odd ciggy then?


getfunky said...

or the odd scoob?


getfunky said...

or the odd line?


GF, none of those are the same as one or two drinks and you know it. You cheapen your argument just by raising them. For the record - no, I don't endorse anyone having the odd ciggy, scoob and certainly not a line, whether they're male or female, pregnant or not. But neither am I endorsing putting a huge guilt trip on a young pregnant woman just because she likes a glass of wine occasionally.


dude, I think that is what he is saying. Just because our culture says it's ok doesn't mean it is. 30 years ago it was considered culturally ok to drink and drive. not so now.
There is a high level of concern among specialists about the current guidelines of alchohol and pregnancy.
It's not worth the risk. http://www.mja.com.au/public/issues/186_01_010107/whi10623_fm.pdf
theDoctor
theDoctor
NSW
5786 posts
NSW, 5786 posts
9 Aug 2010 2:15am
poor relative said...

I worry when bad behaviour is medicalised.
Certianly there are probably circumstances that permit the 'unsoundness of mind' defence but i believe they are rare.

Bad behaviour is exactly that - bad behaviour - and kids who know no boundaries or have never experienced consequences of their actions are more prone to acting out

Kids need stability, security, boundaries, rules and consequences not fkn dexamphetamines or medical diagnosis for bad behaviour





this from the guy who has a psychotropic drug answer to everything not norm

your credibility bounces off the zero point rellie
maxm
maxm
NSW
864 posts
NSW, 864 posts
9 Aug 2010 11:00am
myusernam said...

dude, I think that is what he is saying. Just because our culture says it's ok doesn't mean it is. 30 years ago it was considered culturally ok to drink and drive. not so now.


Mate, dunno about Queensland but here in NSW it is perfectly acceptable to drink and drive - both culturally and legally - as long as you don't exceed the legal limit. I went to a mates barbie yesterday afternoon and probably 40 people did exactly that. I drove home after having one beer and one glass of wine over the space of about 5 hours.

It's all about moderation, you see.
myusernam
myusernam
QLD
6158 posts
QLD, 6158 posts
9 Aug 2010 11:42am
maxm said...

myusernam said...

dude, I think that is what he is saying. Just because our culture says it's ok doesn't mean it is. 30 years ago it was considered culturally ok to drink and drive. not so now.


Mate, dunno about Queensland but here in NSW it is perfectly acceptable to drink and drive - both culturally and legally - as long as you don't exceed the legal limit. I went to a mates barbie yesterday afternoon and probably 40 people did exactly that. I drove home after having one beer and one glass of wine over the space of about 5 hours.

It's all about moderation, you see.


the whole point of this thread is that there is growing medical evidence to suggest that alchohol even in moderation whilst pregnant causes the baby harm.
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
9 Aug 2010 11:14am
maxm said...

getfunky said...

or the odd ciggy then?


getfunky said...

or the odd scoob?


getfunky said...

or the odd line?


GF, none of those are the same as one or two drinks and you know it. You cheapen your argument just by raising them. For the record - no, I don't endorse anyone having the odd ciggy, scoob and certainly not a line, whether they're male or female, pregnant or not. But neither am I endorsing putting a huge guilt trip on a young pregnant woman just because she likes a glass of wine occasionally.


I was just trying to highlight how alchohol in our society gets very little attention to it's detrimental effects.

I think your answer actually reinforces my point. Alarm bells went off at the ciggies, scoob and lines but not alchohol? Why? The grog may well be the most harmful, certainly more harm to foetal development than tar, smack etc. Think I'm exaggerating? Nope.

All of us would scowl seeing a preggo lady sucking on tar (even if it's only one a day) but not a glass of wine?

Fact is 1-2 drinks a day is far more harmful to foetal development than a few ciggies a day.

It is a shame the knowledge isn't out there and that our society turns a complete blind eye to the harm, as most mothers (not breakky-bucket-boguns maybe) would chose not to drink at all if they actually knew the harm.

I'm not trying to judge BTW - just spread the news. As I said I am ever thankful my wife chose not to drink and am embarrassed that 8 yrs ago I was encouraging her to have "Just one glass of wine" while she was up the duff.
poor relative
poor relative
WA
9106 posts
WA, 9106 posts
9 Aug 2010 1:20pm
theDoctor said...

your credibility bounces off the zero point rellie



What if i post a You Tube vid Doc?
would that increase my credibility?
maxm
maxm
NSW
864 posts
NSW, 864 posts
9 Aug 2010 4:04pm
getfunky said...

All of us would scowl seeing a preggo lady sucking on tar (even if it's only one a day)


...well actually no, I wouldn't. I'm not her doctor and I'm not her father. While I might or might not have my own private thoughts, I figure it'd be her lookout and none of my business. So there'd be no scowling involved.

getfunky said...

Fact is 1-2 drinks a day is far more harmful to foetal development than a few ciggies a day.


...which you've previously said causes no harm at all. So how much more is far more? 0.000001% is far more than nothing. Is it worth worrying about? For me, probably not. Others can make up their own minds as suits their personal situation.

getfunky said...

It is a shame the knowledge isn't out there and that our society turns a complete blind eye to the harm, as most mothers (not breakky-bucket-boguns maybe) would chose not to drink at all if they actually knew the harm.


...and good on them if they choose that. But again, I kinda feel it's their choice and none of my business.

getfunky said...

I'm not trying to judge BTW - just spread the news.


which in itself is fine. But then why choose to be so alarmist?
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
9 Aug 2010 2:57pm
Maxm you have entirely missed the point.

Alchohol intake for pregnant women should be thought of in the same way that weed, smack, nicotine already are, and more so, as it appears to be more harmful than those.

The facts and affects are alarming - I am not attempting to be alarming as such.

Bog down in details if you choose to but we all pass judgement (verbally or otherwise - if you want to clech your sphincter about it) when we see a pregnant woman smoking and as time passes you will one day find yourself doing the same when you see a pregnant lady having a 'harmless drink or two'.

Maxm, feel free to take the high ground and pretend you don't judge examples of bad parenting/nurturing if you like. Or be honest.

Geez. The syndrome is real. The affects are out there. Argue about semantics all you like.. or wake up.

EDIT:

In answer to your legitimate question How much more harmful? Obviously you know it's ridiculous to attempt to put a percentage on the damage.

It is relatively early days in research (the problem was 1st taken seriously 30 yrs ago but ignored in the mainstream) as we have had our collective heads in the sand (or porcelain telephone) but it appears the results to date show even moderate and infrequent alchohol intake is harmful. Unless of course you prefer a brain damaged child with physical indicators, lack of concentration, anger control, cognitive abilities etc etc etc etc.

So the safest bet is zero intake.

You don't have to believe me, but if you really want to know the truth (rather than just be the bloke who stuck it to some random dood on Seabreeze) look for the facts and accept it is a real problem in our society.

BTW - I did not suggest ciggies are harmless. They are less harmful than alchohol to an unborn child though.
getfunky
getfunky
WA
4485 posts
WA, 4485 posts
9 Aug 2010 3:09pm
myusernam said...

maxm said...

myusernam said...

dude, I think that is what he is saying. Just because our culture says it's ok doesn't mean it is. 30 years ago it was considered culturally ok to drink and drive. not so now.


Mate, dunno about Queensland but here in NSW it is perfectly acceptable to drink and drive - both culturally and legally - as long as you don't exceed the legal limit. I went to a mates barbie yesterday afternoon and probably 40 people did exactly that. I drove home after having one beer and one glass of wine over the space of about 5 hours.

It's all about moderation, you see.


the whole point of this thread is that there is growing medical evidence to suggest that alchohol even in moderation whilst pregnant causes the baby harm.


As usual someone has said it better than I in 20% (percentage is great) the space I have.
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅