Select to expand quote
Thatspec said..That looks to be just as "in the way" as any wing while downwinding and we'd have to assume it doesn't go upwind quite as well either. Frankly, in the 2.5 - 3.5 range, wings really aren't hindering my downwinding much at all. Sure it's a little harder with a wing in m y hand than a paddle but I get to use a MUCH smaller board and foil.
Really starting to wonder what's behind the anti-wing movement

Hint: (Manufacturers and dealers)
Agree, I don't see it as an upgrade over the wing if that's the dedicated use. However. things keep evolving!
I 100% agree that if you're on a 3.5m or smaller wing it's really not that big of a deal to manage it. It's obviously better to have the wing if you want to session a specific section of swell too.
I think the anti wing movement seems to have strong roots in people that really focused on gen 1 wings or live in lightwind areas and then graduated to dw supfoiling. Modern wings are phenomenal and having learned both dw supfoiling as well as winging I choose the wing every day.