Select to expand quote
Mucel said..
Hi
I must admit I don't like slot box. I think it's not strong enough for the main fin. I'm looking for an allround 95 l trifin wave board and it's difficult to find it with central usbox, and second hand. I would use it in light winds on shore conditions with a 22 cm central fin, and float&ride side shore with 18 cm. I also have many usbox fins I don't want to change.
I would dispute that.
Any box has to take two loads, with the main one being the sideways leverage exerted by the fin's length.
It's like with a fence post in that the higher the fence, the deeper the post end has to be concreted into the ground.
The strength of any fin box is similarly a function of how deep the box is, and of how well it's fixed to the board. In this respect, the Slotbox is just as strong, if not stronger than a US box.
If you want to use a long single fin for freeride blasting, then you are of course better off with a Powerbox or a Tuttle system, because they allow the fin head to be deeper rooted.
In this discussion, the second load on a fin comes from when you hit a rock or ground the fin tip in shallow water, and at that point the load is backwards. A fin with a longer head width can be stronger than a narrower-head fin, but really it's about the fin anchorage system. The US-box fin has a 'tab' section that is designed to break when the fin hits something, whereas the Slotbox relies on the grub screw scraping past the fin's anchoring 'groove'.
At this point there's an argument about whether it's better to lose your fin in a collision - or whether to lose the fin box itself.
I have an 8-year-old Starboard freestyle board that has a 22cms fin fitted in a Slotbox, and it has been trouble-free. Just saying.
I do understand if you sail where there are a lot of rocks, then you might have different finbox preferences.