Well depends, if your running the same sizes in both I'd say the Blade, If your looking at the largest sail for your mast (in my case a 400) then comparing my 2011 5.0 blade to my 2010 5.6 S1, I can tighten the leach with my downhaul adjustment to give me that little bit power on and go when it super light on my S1 and I'd use it in less than 15kts, any more then I'd be switching over to the Blade. If I had a 430 mast then I'd go for S1's in sizes over 5.6 as they're very well balanced for big size sail and super light and IMO easier to stuff around with in marginal winds.
I'm 78kgs with 77ltr board with blades, and 83ltr using the 5.6...
S1 - (notice leach is cut fuller) - on 83ltr board in 'bout 12kts
New blades below - leech is trimmed and power released earlier
That's my 2 cents...