Mark , through my expirence this is my conclusion till now and maybe it will help out other guys !!! , i know u know what i know but its a good topic...
Speedboards are designed "as u know" for small chop to flat water and most importantly consistant strong wind or u could say stable wind as soon as you dont have any of these factors your speedboard does not work efficiantly anymore !!!1
I have pushed speedboards through heavy chop and yes u can be fast on it but you will be just as fast on a high wind slalom board or even faster in those kind of conditions , and believe u me it is way more easier to ride through heavy chop on a slalom board than a speedboard and way more comfortable , and comfortable means u can push harder !!!!
I know i have in the past misinterpeted how good is your speedboard at your local spot , well back in brisi is no good unless u get some consistant nuking wind for your speedboard to work well , when it comes to chop forget about it , u can ride through it but your preformance will be low...
well goin back to your question , not all speedboards are designed for open water speedsailing or into heavier chop , thats why we have on the market now speedboards that are strictly designed for flat water and there are very few that are designed for choppier waters , meaning while you go through your run on flat water u will at the end end up in choppier waters and thats where u want the board to work properly so u can get to a safe stop!!!
So my conclusion and what i have tested that speedboards dont mix in open water speedsailing or goin into heavy chop , they are not quicker in these conditions !!!!
Here is my last session on a slalom board transfering it into a speedboard version , so the question would be would i have gone quicker on the speedboard , well hard to say it was pretty choppy and gusty and trying out before hand on the speedboard was pretty hard on the feet and a very bumpy ride but the speeds were a tad lower but with the slalom board automatically full control easy to ride and hovered over the chop..
But if the water was flat then yes the speedboard would have excelled!!
gpsteamchallenge.com.au/sailor_session/show?date=2014-04-04&team=41www.gps-speedsurfing.com/default.aspx?mnu=user&val=146919&uid=1599Again speedsailing in choppy waters needs tunning your sail properly , i tend to put a good amount of DH to first gain control , under DH will cause to much power to control and it gets harder...
Fin size has to be bigger so you dont get spinouts and so the fin is almost always incontact with the water , but putting a bigger fin in a 50 wide speedboard is not a solution that will definatly crank your ankles creating alot of power and that will equal drag .... and not all fins will work on the same speedboard ...
Bottom shape of the board is the key element , like i said before majority of the brands today are designed for flat water , and very few for allrounder...
I know when i was on carbon art speedboards 50 n 44 they worked great in flat water to small chop but as soon as it starts to get hectic mate they where so hard to ride in the messy chop goin upwind, crosswind let alone downwind , like you said ankle killer!!!!....
From today i have tested out the mistral speed 55 n 47 and by looking at there bottom shape design they are made for an allrounder but still to a certain degree but way better than the carbon arts ...
But at the end of the day in conditions of 18 to 30+kts in medium choppy waters i would stick to a high wind slalom board , way quicker and way better handling in the chop and more fun to ride and you get more runs in !!!!