There's been a bit of discussion on another forum about this.

If you become a member on, say, the 20th of the month, should you be allowed to post your scores for the 19th of that month?


Just after some other ideas.

Select to expand quote

nebbian said...

There's been a bit of discussion on another forum about this.

If you become a member on, say, the 20th of the month, should you be allowed to post your scores for the 19th of that month?


Just after some other ideas.

No

I see no problem with someone posting their month's sessions prior to joining say by the middle (e.g. 15th) of said month, unless of course they're Dutch then Frant's ruling would be invoked

Select to expand quote

nebbian said...

There's been a bit of discussion on another forum about this.

If you become a member on, say, the 20th of the month, should you be allowed to post your scores for the 19th of that month?


Just after some other ideas.

I'm not sure we ever formalised it, but early on the understanding was if you registered then you could post any session in the month you registered? (if my memory serves me correctly)

Select to expand quote

hardie said...

nebbian said...

There's been a bit of discussion on another forum about this.

If you become a member on, say, the 20th of the month, should you be allowed to post your scores for the 19th of that month?


Just after some other ideas.

I'm not sure we ever formalised it, but early on the understanding was if you registered then you could post any session in the month you registered? (if my memory serves me correctly)

Then my answer is yes. Just make a decision Yes or No. Publish the decision. We have enough electoral decisions to make without putting this one to public opinion.

i see its pretty simple. Once you join up you can post from that date forward. What competitions can you compete in before you have registered??

Select to expand quote

Bender said...

i see its pretty simple. Once you join up you can post from that date forward. What competitions can you compete in before you have registered??

I think that might be what Hardie was saying. If you join in month of July then you can post for month of July.

Select to expand quote

frant said...

Bender said...

i see its pretty simple. Once you join up you can post from that date forward. What competitions can you compete in before you have registered??

I think that might be what Hardie was saying. If you join in month of July then you can post for month of July.

cool so i can post times from july 07

Select to expand quote

hardie said...

nebbian said...

There's been a bit of discussion on another forum about this.

If you become a member on, say, the 20th of the month, should you be allowed to post your scores for the 19th of that month?


Just after some other ideas.

I'm not sure we ever formalised it, but early on the understanding was if you registered then you could post any session in the month you registered? (if my memory serves me correctly)

As the GPS challenge is a monthly competition rather than a daily one, that seems fair.

And if the site currently allows you to post for the whole of the beginning month, there's no new work for Nebs!!!!
I'd go with whatever the site currently allows.
I certainly see no need to make alterations just to restrict a new member to only posting after the day they joined.

I dont think your results prior to GTC receiving the waiver form should count.
just my thoughts

Doesn't bother me, but if posting sessions from earlier that month encourages 1 person to join up then I say let ém post