Select to expand quote
decrepit said..
The one thing that springs to mind, is very heavy weed on the surface of shallow water. The water can be super smooth in quite high wind strengths. But a normal weedy has fairly high drag in the weed. Deltas are a big improvement, but I suspect they can be improved on.
My thought is that the normal approach to induced drag goes out the window in shallow weedy water, as the bottom and the weed are an impediment to flow around the tip.
Lake George doesn't quite fit this, as most of the time the weed isn't that heavy, but I have seen areas in shallow water, where the weed is much heavier. But it's normally avoided because there are vast areas, with water only slightly less flat, but with much less dragy weed
weed fins are a tricky business... but you are right there is lots of room for improvement.
i've made a full set of proto weed fins at 48deg rake for testing a while ago and have got really good feedback on them, but unfortunately they were never viable to be made as a production fin that fin in with the C3 business philosophy.
the problems we encountered to ever get them off the ground as production fins were:
1) small speed fins needed to be fine tuned in rake angle depending on where you are sailing. you can get optimum performance when covering all states of weed.
if you go with a lot of rake angle to cover heavy surface weed you loose performance in conditions that don't require quite that much rake. so that small market gets fragmented into very small amounts of finely specialised fins. not good for production fins that need to be ordered by the G10 panel per size.
2) small slalom fins face a similar problem, with the need to tune the rake angle as upright as possible for the conditions you encounter, plus these fins made in G10 become quite heavy and are getting expensive due to the odd nesting layout on the G10 sheets. of course you could make them in a moulded technology to reduce the weight, but you would certainly lose durability compared to G10 which might be quite important in shallow conditions.
3) the big slalom weed fins i made didn't seem to have no straight line speed problem at the top end at all, but the biggest one i made [with an equivalent power of a Sting45] starts to get a bit more challenging to gybe due to the long chord length at the base. plus those sizes you would really only want make in a moulded technology as production fin, as they will be prohibitively expensive in G10 due to the geometry and the biggest one came in at a hefty 1.2kg

i'm pretty confident that with a bit of development work the performance and usability of weed fins can be improved... quite a bit.
not so sure that we will ever be able to sail super fast in constant heavy weed conditions. there is a huge difference between shedding the odd strand of weed or sailing through a patch and constantly having weed sliding off the fin, that might just be too much drag to really make it fast.
i'll see if i can find some pictures of the proto fins i made.
cheers
Boogie