it sounds like you have cross threaded the the thread and thought you had it tight

either way you will have to fix and make sure both threads are cleaned up,once you have water in your board you will never get it all out, therefore a chance of delam futher down the track, so take the tip from decrepit and get a goretex, there not hard to fit, i imagine bennets would tell you what size hole you will need and glue it in with aroldite, i allways use a single glass roveing to wrap the goretex houseing but it's not necessary