Back to top

Which boom size - 140-190 or 150-200?

Created by NormannD NormannD  > 9 months ago, 27 Aug 2018
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
NormannD
NormannD

14 posts

27 Aug 2018 10:42pm
Hi,
I am currently sailing a 150-210 simmerstyle blackline 2018 model, but i dont really fancy the tapered tubes (25 mm for front hand and fat (28mm?) for back hand). I got this boom as a replacement for the 150-210 simmerstyle blackline 2017 which i snapped after af few rides...
Before the 2017 boom i snapped a simmerstyle blackline 140-190 after two seasons of use.
Not very lucky with the simmerstyle booms

I am therefore considering buying an AL360 slim boom after i tried one at pozowinds and really liked it!
But... I am in doubt whether to go for the 140-190 or 150-200. I sail in waves.
My smallest sail 4.0 needs 151 for the boom. If i upgrade my 4.0 to the new model it would need 148 for the boom. I mostly use my simmerstyle blacktip 5.0 which needs 168 cm, but i also have a 5.8 (184) that I rearly use. I am considering replacing it with a 5.6 blacktip with a boom of 173 or 5.9 icon with a boom of 180.

I consider the 150-200 for durability reasons as it would be less extended. I really dont want to break another boom again.

What do you guys think?

PS. I am 92 Kg
Mastbender
Mastbender

1972 posts

28 Aug 2018 1:59am
It would depend on where your booms snapped, if you are really concerned about extension.
But boom strength isn't really defined around the assumption that you are using minimal extension.
NormannD
NormannD

14 posts

29 Aug 2018 10:32pm
Snapped my first carbon boom 40 cm behind the harness lines. The simmerstyle blackline carbon snapped 20 cm behind the harness lines at 20 cm extension using a 5.0 sail.
Anyone got any experiences using a AL360 boom at fairly large extension regarding flex/feel?
stehsegler
stehsegler

WA

3557 posts

30 Aug 2018 9:46am
Get a Severne Enigma Wave 150-200. Best boom I have ever owned. Awesome reduced diameter grip and stays stiff for a long time.
westozwind
westozwind

WA

1416 posts

30 Aug 2018 10:32am
Same goes for the NeilPryde X9 140-190. Rock solid and replacement parts still avaliable for older models.
Mark _australia
Mark _australia

WA

23526 posts

30 Aug 2018 11:47am
For me the Blackline is the only one that really lasts.
Never seen one broken, so I hope its not a problem with 2018 ones.....

Anyway I reckon go the 150, but you don't have that choice in AL360
Manuel7
Manuel7

1331 posts

31 Aug 2018 2:29am
Maybe you can repair it?
Relic
Relic

TAS

837 posts

31 Aug 2018 7:23am
Select to expand quote
Manuel7 said..
Maybe you can repair it?



I repaired a Billows carbon boom which was toast. Stronger than new now.
If you're interested I can run you through the technique. P .M. Me.
End of posts
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site