Select to expand quote
segler said..
People seem to decry the accuracy of the Garmin. I don't get that.
Several times I have gone out with Garmin 5X, Garmin 245 Music, GW-60, two Timex Ironman GPS watches, and XOSS G biking GPS, all strapped to the top of my helmet. Eastern Washington state Columbia Basin, latitude 47 deg N, on the bike over a 7 miles course, all in open country with no buildings or power poles or mountains, or even trees. I think this simulates our on-water conditions the best. Logging rates were 0.5 Hz on the Timex, 1 Hz on both Garmins and XOSS, and 5 Hz on the GW-60, with no use of "smart" or variable logging. Except for the GW-60, all save data to FIT files. K888 has commented that most watches likely collect speed data as doppler, and that the doppler speeds are recorded in the FIT files. Only the GW-60 reports HDOP data.
Using CALTOPO all of their tracks overlay each other to within a meter or two every time I have tried this. All report the same max speeds within 0.2 mph. So they are all equally inaccurate or equally accurate.
Select to expand quote
segler said..
People seem to decry the accuracy of the Garmin. I don't get that.
Several times I have gone out with Garmin 5X, Garmin 245 Music, GW-60, two Timex Ironman GPS watches, and XOSS G biking GPS, all strapped to the top of my helmet. Eastern Washington state Columbia Basin, latitude 47 deg N, on the bike over a 7 miles course, all in open country with no buildings or power poles or mountains, or even trees. I think this simulates our on-water conditions the best. Logging rates were 0.5 Hz on the Timex, 1 Hz on both Garmins and XOSS, and 5 Hz on the GW-60, with no use of "smart" or variable logging. Except for the GW-60, all save data to FIT files. K888 has commented that most watches likely collect speed data as doppler, and that the doppler speeds are recorded in the FIT files. Only the GW-60 reports HDOP data.
Using CALTOPO all of their tracks overlay each other to within a meter or two every time I have tried this. All report the same max speeds within 0.2 mph. So they are all equally inaccurate or equally accurate.
Totally agree , but unfortunately a few gps sailors are obsessed with accuracy too 2 decimal points. GPSTC started out being fun and inclusive but I feel it's not changing with the times. If we aren't carefull the only people in the comp will be ones that can build there own GPS (I think Julian form motion is doing a fantastic job and a great product but if he shuts shop where are we then...)