Dunno what the fuss is about with booties, if you wear them enough you'll get used to the feeling!
In the past 11 years of living on the south coast of WA using booties all year round (due to usual launch areas), I've tried just about every brand of high cut surf/windsurf bootie thats readily available in WA (i.e. Billabong, O'Neil, Rip Curl, Neil Pryde but not Flying Objects though) both in round and split toe. Currently using high cut Neil Pryde booties (with side entry zippers) I got from Windsurfing Perth many years ago that have lasted heaps longer than the others which all fell apart in less than two years. Have tried to find replacements but NP apparently does not import them into country any more. Zippered booties are great if you can get them, always struggled getting pull on boots on or off!
One thing that made a huge difference to keeping my feet warm during winter sailing was to wear thick woolen socks under my booties (or high wool content if you can't find pure wool socks). My feet used to get so cold and numb before doing this, now my fingers are the problem!
Also wear a 'Roaster' thermal rash vest with a fleecy inner lining (called Thermax) under 3mm long john to keep torso warm.
Check out related topic on Kitesurfing forum:
www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Kitesurfing/General/Wetsuit-Booties-2/(obviously more concern about style and comfort then practical reasons for wearing booties!)