Easty I have had similar experience. The EVO was perfect (better than perfect

) in down the line waves. When I moved to another spot that was very choppy it was a pain in the arse. This was a place with a long choppy run out to the reef break and very windy.
At one stage I was using 4.0 and 80L EVO (and I'm 100kg so it was damn windy!). My knees and ankles hurt from the pounding over chop. I thought it was a dumb idea cos it was so windy but I went for my new RRD 101FSW just to see how it felt. Too keen to use it. Seriously what wavesailor uses 100L on a 30-35kn day? Well it was better, I was really confused. I tried my old old 74L Acid. Again, better.
Then I realised it was all in the vee.
Real world waves and EVO's etc have funny concave things going on, they are absolutely awesome in the waves but if it is 800m of chop to get to the wave they are very hard to handle.
I'd still take the EVO any day on crossshore head hi beach break, but not on the insane B&J days with a bit of wave riding.
Interesting, another case of old school shaping may be better for most people most of the time?.