Select to expand quote
Faff said..mr love said..
OK.....each to their own....I was windfoiling last week in up to 35 knots.......the wingers all holding their wings above their heads to depower looked awkward and painful......I had my hands full but quite doable, then the wind died and they all struggled to get home with some big walks of shame and I just cruised in. The old windfoil gear was pretty crap and I find you get opinions from guys that tried it when it first came out using unstable rubbish foils and now they wingfoil on modern gear and say its much better., but they have not used new really good windfoil kit. As far as depowering on a swell...you learn how to do it and it feels very natural...but you need a wave sail, cammed sails dont dump the power.
I bought a wing and a board , buckled to peer group pressure...tried it twice and went...WTF am I learning something new for when I am loving what I am doing now. I may get it out again over summer but not that motivated to.
But early wingfoils were just as bad or worse (huge, draggy 2000 cm2 spades). And at least in windfoiling one could rely on decent rigs right from the start; first couple of generations of hand wings were trash. But yeah, going from a first gen windfoil to a 3rd gen wingfoil may have colored my perceptions.
I think there is some psycological trick our mind is playing with us. This was happening when I was suggesting windsurfer to start windfoling...they started to be immediately defensive, so I stopped. The reason why I believe is because they invested so much in getting where they are in windsurfing (some not still able to do a decent power jibe though), that was mentally refusing to start again the learning curve for anything else. I had myself the same when somebody suggested winging to be interesting, but I wanted to play tricks with my mind and give it a try...found it interesting enoungh to do more...but not to abandon windfoil by any mean. I see winging is having quite a boost and technology especially on hand wings is improving very fast, my Echo is rubbish compared to 2023 wings out there, so at the moment winging has more margins for improvement vs windfoiling which from a market perspective is perceived as a nice expecially out of the IQ/racing envelope.
I you love sport and you are or have been teaching sports as myself, you get curious on what are the common biomechanics, and what the differences. I love windfoiling and will continue to do it, but there has been cases when I whished to be winging to avoid loosing a windy day opportunity I couldn't grasp with the windfoil..you know: logistics, crowded beach, no place to rig, ..in some cases winging can make it better, that is all, moreover from what I could see winging not being the sail conneted to the board allow to direct the pull in any direction and copy with gusty condition a little better and have a greater wind range you can use a sail for.
when windsurfers tell me...'so we will all be windfoiling then?' with sad faces...this makes me laugh and respond ...'no of course we are here for fun and you are free to have fun with whatever you prefer...no obligation'...