Yep, mine wore out really fast this year. Picked up some spare ones at the hardware store. These plastic vent screws are screwy. You can't tighten them like the metal vent screws. The plastic can't be tightened as nearly as tight because you will strip the head of the screw and crush the washer. So I just snug the plastic screw up against the washer not too tight, then back the screw off a hair, then back snug again, then back off a hair again and re-snug. I do this about 3-4 times to make sure the plug is well seated against the washer, creating a slight bond, but not crushing the washer. If I snug it up too tight, the head of the screw will mushroom the washer, and will take on a slight amount of water. If the screw isn't tight enough, then you will take water in as well. It seems to be a skill in itself just to snug up a stupid vent screw. But it's now mastered!!
