Thinking of going with a bigger rubber washer. Might be overkill but can't hurt. Still original sized stainless washer for now until I find one slightly bigger. Seems silly why manufacturers wouldn't give you a bigger(wider) washer to try to utilize all the space in that recessed part of the fin box to help distribute the force more. Just my $0.02
Just put a dab of epoxy on. If I keep on making small repairs like this epoxy will last a lifetime