Select to expand quote
2keen said..Paducah said..
Edit: btw, I know of no instance anyone has ever said the 65 is slow. I'm open to evidence suggesting otherwise.
WoH said
" A small low aspect wing is just a low aspect wing for more wind, sure its a little faster"
Pretty sure WoH's opinion is that low aspect wings are slow
Did you really mean to use that quote? Because it's about an entirely different brand of foil and comparing two low aspect designs in that brand.
WoH's comments were in response steview asking about the Starboard Supercruiser 1700 and 1200. He followed what you quoted with this (bold mine)
"Remember, a high aspect wing gives about 1,5-2x times as much power / lift as a similarly sized low aspect wing. In the end, a 1100cm2 high aspect will give the same, if not more early lift than your
supercruiser, with more speed and more glide through lulls."
www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Windsurfing/Foiling/Higher-aspect-foil-for-foil-x-145-2#8This matches Azymuth's experience with his comparing the 65 which is almost half the size of the 76 but he feels like it only gives up 10-15% of the lift but gains the same in speed (and since drag increases exponentially with speed, means the 65 is roughly 30% more slippery)
WoH on similar sized gear is at another level in speed (29 kts) from most people in this conversation
www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Windsurfing/Foiling/Top-speed-for-Infinity-65-and-Warp-Speed?page=1 If he feels lower aspect foils are slower, from where he sits, he can say that in my book.
Interestingly, in that thread which is specifically about the I65, I don't see where WoH made any negative comments about the 65. If he thought it was a slow wing, that would have been a good time to mention it. Instead, he made the constructive comment that a SS event would be a good opportunity for SS riders to compare their experiences on their specific foils. And, in that same thread, other SS riders clearly show what the speeds of the various wings are. Bigger, lower aspect wings are slower.
Azymuth, I appreciate your input. Any discussions of wings is not intended to diminish your stoke, ride or enjoyment. To quote you from the i65 discussion I linked: "For me the real fun is flying at 20+ knots while carving a 90 degree turn on a 2m windswell downwind." Keep it up on whatever gear works for you, sir.