Select to expand quote
CJW said...terminal said...
Sailrocket has quite a windsurfer-like design, so a variation of it would be what I would think would be the fastest. Sailrocket was designed almost without design restrictions, so it would be very hard to beat - especially if they scale it up.
The only advantage a windsurfer might bring would be quicker reactions and more sensitivity.
We still need to see how far the current design of windsurfer can go as they are going much faster than the windspeed now in 40 knots of wind, and we need to see what a windsurfer can do in 50 to 60 knots of wind.
Sailrocket is much more efficient, going at perhaps 2+ times the speed of the wind, so will get many more opportunities to set new records than if needing to wait for 60 knots.
The genius of Sailrocket is how the force from the sail is reacted into the foil, they have totally eliminated righting moment from the equation. This enables them to hold down massive amounts of power = overcoming drag. Their biggest issue is foil cavitation which they seem to be on top of.
Neither a windsurfer or a kite has this luxury and in both of their current forms it's just not possible to compete purely on a power/drag basis. Kites and windsurfers are both at this point chasing efficiency, which is why we have seen such small incremental improvements, but the laws of diminishing returns are already well in play, imo of course.
The elimination of righting moment is a good thing in that its the resistance of the foil that is key, so you dont need the weight of the rider to be hiked out on an outrigger - in theory.
The problems will be:-
That to streamline, the rider has to lie down. The only alternative might be to have him inside the luff of the sail and control it from there.
There is such an idea already, and the sail size can be increased to maybe 20m because the rider doesn't have to hold it down.
The rider has to control the sail and the foil and he will be somewhere in between the two (or in the luff).
How to get the thing planing in the first place.