To be honest I went down the 'research' path when I was recently in the market for a new board. Only conclusion I got was to get an epoxy and surf it to find out for myself.
For every positive comment there was a negative one and the reasons vary from the type of wave people surfed to the way they feel under foot to just what people are used to. Get a hold of a good quality secondhand one and give it a red hot go.
I got one recently and have found good and bad about it, it does somethings really well and I can also see the some issues. I have not surfed it enough to make up my mind yet but keen to keep using it til I do