Unsure of just how gutless a wave you're talking, but check out these boards.
www.softechsoftboards.com/collections/boardsMuch tougher construction than your El Nino flexi crap. I've got the 5'10" fish tail signature. Have owned plenty of softboards (and broken them). These ones are gold. Had a ball pulling into 1ft closeouts last night. Quad setup, wide boards. You can literally get into everything with ease. Perhaps not as easy to turn as fibreglass, but you can genuinely catch the smallest waves and get through fat sections with ease. You'll also find very few used ones being sold. People don't get rid of them once they have them.