I've got 2 friends who have them, both are about as fat as me, maybe ones a bit bigger, (I hope he is, I'd hate to think I've got a gut like his).
The board catches wave well for both guys, but I would not say it's a hot performer, but neither are they, they're just happy to stand up.
I think the boards are almost 4 inches thick
One is still riding his and seems happy, the other one was always complaining that the glassing job on his epoxy model was too thin and prone to damage.
About 3 months ago, I sold him my Clearwater hot log because it did not suit me. Since that day, he's never touched the Magic and he now catching more waves than at any time in his life.
So there you go, one guy hated the magic, the other guy loves it.
One guy hated the the hot log, the other guy loved it.