The Evo II summary from the McT website:
The sportier version of the Fireball model, our great all-rounder. More slanted towards performance surfing... And some good comments from the enigmatic Simondo here:
www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Surfing/Longboarding/McTavish-EvoII-Review/ And from another first-time longboarder like yourself, TDog, here:
www.seabreeze.com.au/forums/Surfing/Longboarding/The-Blue-Dream-Custom-Fireball-Evo-II/ including "...never did wrap this thread up properly so I'll have a go at a review. Can't really compare it to other boards though this is my first LB. Like Blair said back at the beginning of the thread, the EVOII is a forgiving board but I also find it responsive and super fun! At 9.1x 22 3/4 x2 7/8 it's been a great transition board for me as a long time short boarder. It thrives on long point waves at about 2-4' or slightly bigger. Narrower width is great for cutties and carving off the tail

though makes nose riding less stable but I'm frequently in the front 1/2-1/3 of the board and have lots of fun up there

The 3 profile rocker seems to work nicely with plenty of nose and tail rocker for steeper take offs. Decent tail rocker also helps with turning, and flat middle section is the sweet spot for trimming and gliding through the flat sections

Does it sound like I love it? because I do

and can see why so many others are fans of this shape!"
Sure, consider other boards too. But don't rule out the Evo II. It's a beauty.