I reckon the 8ball for the older surfer if it's for small waves ect.it would probably carry you better and be more stable. Another board that's well worth a look is a Miller Powerglide. They paddle very well ,nose ride a bit and good off the tail.
He is in Sydney and on the web on Miller Surfboards. The quality of these boards is up there with the best of them and he,s a champion of a bloke to deal with. Here's mine. It just looks like a run of the mill mini mal but anyone who has ever had a go on it has really liked it.