Hey Dan - not sure what you have lined up in the surftech boards but if you can, try to get a run on a Takayama Kai Sallas model, Takayama Stephen Slater (slightly more beachy oriented), Dino Miranda 9'0, - just to name a couple. The Kai Sallas Takayama is a very very nice board and a very performance oriented all-rounder for a lighter rider.
Tuflites are insane and hold up so much better than any pu board ever will. Yes - tuflites will break just like any board if you put them in the wrong place at the wrong time, but they are so resistant to everyday dings and depressions and its a nice feeling when you clean your wax off every coupla months and there aren't any deck depressions - kinda makes you glad you spent the extra dollars. No - I don't work for surftech

I just love em and always have.