Wimpy, i just fall in when my feet get a bit sore, crocs can work, or I like neoprene booties and rip curl reef booties. Have you tries the nash grip, its kinda more tacky than others, my starboard grip is way less comfortable to stand on over time.
Ive seen those quicksilver shoes too,
Vibram do a shoe for sup which might be your answer,
us.vibram.com/shop/fivefingers/men/watersports/signa---mens-M02.html?dwvar_M02_color=Black%20%2F%20Yellowcheck it out and also any good boat shoe form a yachting background should be tacky enough.