Select to expand quote
tamarackjanito said..
. I was wondering if the boards were tough to go from rail to rail and to do deep cuts and bottom turns but it looks like they handle just fine. I like the idea. I just have a different mind set.
Well, I think like everything in surfing, they are just a compromise: they are easier to throw around, but on good waves, a longer board is more confortable, as you can lay on the rail with all your force, with a shorter board it is easy to turn too much or too little.
Wider boards need also more footwork.
They are easier to surf the foam with, more compact.
they can be harder to push through whitewater: more width and less room for error
ghost, this is why I advocate wide enough boards to be confortable and never knee paddle. I posted those pics to show that boards can turn even if not 24" wide... I agree that you do need more timing and precise positioning to get into the wave, rather than raw power. Getting a tad off-balance and putting your weight on your heels stop the takeoff for instance, that's the main hurdle to overcome in chop with them.
Again, the idea is not to say that short SUP boards are the only kind of boards to use, nor are a kind of "evolution pinnacle". Just to dispell the misconceptions that "they do not turn properly" "they can only dishpan" "they are just ugly discs" and have shop vendors sell Hawaiians narrow guns for SUPers in everyday waves... again last week some surfer wanted to learn SUPing on a 8'x26" because he got the ideas from mags that thses boards were much better than the others because he saw them in contests...
Give me a 6' wave face, and I am quite happy with a 8' SUP :-)