Spencer,I have had both boards,IMO,given your local is a longboard wave,you need to be really honest in your ability,I moved the band b on quickly as it was a VERY slow paddler. The reason it noserides so well is the amount of drag that's required to pull the board back into the pocket,and believe me you can feel the drag when paddling ,with a log long boarding background I can noserider,the B and B definitely does this ! For me I can not afford specialist boards so my choice is the striker as a one board quiver.At 10 ft it should handle your weight plus the strikers paddle brilliantly,with the edge in the tail they do not drag,yet still noseride very well! and performance surf to! Also the striker flat water paddles very well as I do a lot of cross training for fitness ( on going shoulder problems),hope this helps with your decision