Select to expand quote
SUPNoob said..
would it be realistic for me to expect to catch waves with this board after some (a lot of) practice?
The problem with surf-based sports (surfing, SUP, ...) is that you practice only when you catch waves.
And so, having a board too hard for your level will reduce your wave count, reducing the rate of your progression immensely.
I have seen people that insisted that they were very happy with their small board but catching one wave in a hour instead of the 30 their should have caught with a bigger board. This means they progressed 30 times slower. And since we were in a place with infrequent waves, and they could only get out on week-ends, it would have been taken them years, even decades, to progress. Needless to say, they quit after some years.
This said, he was on a 7'4" and should have been on a 10'. This is more as a general warning.
10' and 11' are close enough that you can have easier 10' boards than 11' ones, depending on their width, shape and volume.
The Evoke seems a fine board, but not with the easiest shape however (pulled in tail and semi-pulled-in nose), so I'd advise also on the 10'6" or 11'. The 10' would have been OK if you already have some surfing experience to know how to catch waves.