Well, I am just a recent Simmons convert, so I can only share my limited experience. I can only compare these shapes I have ridden a lot:
A wombat-like quad, Gong Mutant 2011 6'9"
(Center) A bit the same kind of shape, but with double winger, Gong One 6'8", 5 fins
A Simmons Gong AS 8', with 2 keel fins on the tail
The first 2 shapes are very fun and fast, but are ridden more like a compromise between a fish and a traditional mini-mal surfboard. The Simmons, on the other hand, has more latency, it likes getting up to speed,and them banked into turns like a (very nimble) plane. I'd say that plenty of shapes will work, but differently, and fin placement can change drastically the feel of a board.
How this is the result of the rear outline curves/hips, I couldn't say. I would suspect the fin placement & rear concave are the most important. Dimensions of the boards can be found on the Gong site.
PS: yes, I think all english-speaking should leave standupzone for seabreeze (or ideally, a SUP forum not depending on SUP ads). The recent heavy hidden censorship on standupzone totally destroys any attempt to any meaningful technical discussion. My account have even been banned, so I cannot even see my MPs there...