Select to expand quote
Simsurf said..
Hi all.
i'm a bit late to this conversation but trying to decide between a 9'4 Creek and a 9'4" Placid. Seems like a bit of experience on here with both so looking for some advice and detailed feedback on your experiences I am 6'5" and 100kg. Intermediate but can hold my own and throw a board around ok Main surf spot is mellow reef break chest high to overhead. Looking for a board to throw around a bit more, bounce off sections and full rail cutbacks. Stability is a must to remove the swim time on the choppier days.
Any and all advice appreciated
Simon
Hi Simon
Both VERY different boards.
I'll try to compare them... but it's apples and oranges.
Beware all who like one word answers to complex questions.... I only have one speed.

OK Simon, your size is a big factor here... more involved than sufficient volume.
FYI:
I will routinely run my own "stability tests"
I take 5 or 6 boards to a calm flat-water landing, put them all side by side and film myself, using 2 cameras
Stability
The Creek:
I designed the 9'4, for me at 106 kg (5'10) in full winter gear, so I added some "stability tools"... meaning
slightly fuller nose and reasonable width...
BUT, it is
not a "stability board"... it's a performance board, that isn't impossible to stand on.
I have a 9'1 and a 9'4. I almost never ride my 9'1.
I
have also surfed the 8'10 without struggle... but, the 9'4 gives me much better overall performance because it keeps me "powered up" in all situations. I think the Creek is best with more surface area, than less.
The Creek has a very sweet tail carve and likes full rail cutbacks.
The channels carve, but resists sliding the tail out, for a quick snap.
It handles anything, so a great travel board.
also, I still think this is the fastest board I have surfed.... Bert nailed the rocker or something

The Placid:
I feel this
is a "stability board" because: it is
so darn stable... it really is.
Even at 72 and 106 kg, I could probably ride the 8'7 without too much problem.
I have the 9'1, but have an 8'10 coming next week... I will sell my 9'1 to facilitate the upgrade.
Why?
Like Can'tSUPenough, I have a love/hate relationship with my 9'1 Placid.
First 3 sessions... like CSE... I couldn't turn it. Perfect 5' glassy waves. I'd throw a turn and the board would simply go straight.
I NEVER struggle to turn a board backside.... but I fell off the Placid on
every backside bottom turn.
Ran as Thruster, quad, Twinzer with small center... nothing worked for me.
After 3 sessions I put it away... for good.
When I got home to Cape Cod.... I decided I HAD to come to terms with it.
Crappy, windy, rainy day. 3' bumpy lumps... I figured "Why not, it's not like I'll blow a good session"

I went quad, with tiny rears... tiny, like 3.5" and short base (not nubs)
Wow... it became loose and snappy!

Super fun!
Loved the loose tail, BUT.... the nose felt piggish and in the way.
The nose on the 9'1 is very big, but that's why it's so stable.... so I am hoping the smaller 8'10 will play better for me.
The tail will get you to the lip with ease.... or slide into a nice slashing cutback.
It really is an interesting board... and it has turned me into a "tiny rear" quad guy

I ordered more baby backs to run in all my quads!
I agree it's a bit on the slow side, but that plays well for snapping quick turns.
Overall, I think it's the most stable of all Sunova's except for a few in the GenRation line.
It might be perfect for a mellow reef break from chest to OH.
at 6'5, I would not go any smaller than a 9'4 Creek... whereas the 9'1 Placid should be fine.
Very different boards, so it depends what appeals to you most.
The forward Quads in this pic are pretty small as well, so I included a pic of my rears, next to a stock Sunova 105 side
Stability testing helps me answer questions about similar and dissimilar shapes and volumes.
I record all my tests with 2 cameras
I constantly refer to these videos when I get stability questions... because it's very easy to mis-remember how different boards measure up.

My Soloshot to see how they sit in the water

my "Kook Hat Cam" records my candid impressions and records a good look at how the rails sit in the water
Placid 9'1

Creek 9'4