Back to top

Full keel yachts like Compass 28/29.

Created by Harks Harks  > 9 months ago, 11 Jul 2020
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Harks
Harks

3 posts

11 Jul 2020 4:45pm
Hey there my name is Hakan, you doin good? Looking into sailing for the next stage of my life, currently 35. And decided to go for a slower, safer full keel cruiser which I can sail by my self. I like The Compass 28/29 from the late 70's and 80's and seen the H28 variations too. Wondering though, What are other full keel cruisers around the same era? No longer than 30 feet and around 20k give or take. Because even though Compass seem to have a good reputation. They're missing the cutaway from the man hole, excuse me if it's not called that but you know what I mean. So yeah. Which full keel yachts do you like from the 70's which are around 30 feet and around 20kCheers lads. - Harks.
cisco
cisco

QLD

12364 posts

11 Jul 2020 10:46pm
Clansman. Bullet proof and not slow if you sail them hard.

sailboatdata.com/sailboat/clansman-30

yachthub.com/list/yachts-for-sale/used/sail-monohulls/clansman-30/219508
Harks
Harks

3 posts

11 Jul 2020 9:03pm
Select to expand quote


Yeah something like that.

Thanks.

I must be in the naive, early stages of sailing because, I think I am gonna sail that thing around the world...maybe just Asia to begin with.
Charriot
Charriot

QLD

880 posts

12 Jul 2020 4:02am
Duncanson 29
Ramona
Ramona

NSW

7737 posts

12 Jul 2020 8:20am
Nicholson 32 is outside your sail requirements but is a better long keeler. Not many come up for sale, owners tend to hold on to them. Sell between 10 and 20 grand usually. Twice the interior room of a Compass 29. I'm not keen on the hard dodger on this one but it does have an Aries.
www.boatsonline.com.au/boats-for-sale/used/sailing-boats/camper-nicholson-32-mk-x/247471
Andrew68
Andrew68

VIC

433 posts

12 Jul 2020 9:20am
Hey there,

My experience is that if you are going to extensively cruise a $20k yacht, then the purchase cost will only be a fraction of the ongoing costs. The cost to keep at 33' boat will be very similar to a 28' boat, but the additional amenity, cruise speed and internal space is massive.
Make sure the rig, engine, keel, rudder are good and decks are not soft as theses can cost more than the entire boat to replace.

A
r13
r13

r13

NSW

1714 posts

12 Jul 2020 9:54am
Select to expand quote
Ramona said..
Nicholson 32 is outside your sail requirements but is a better long keeler. Not many come up for sale, owners tend to hold on to them. Sell between 10 and 20 grand usually. Twice the interior room of a Compass 29. I'm not keen on the hard dodger on this one but it does have an Aries.
www.boatsonline.com.au/boats-for-sale/used/sailing-boats/camper-nicholson-32-mk-x/247471


This one?

yachthub.com/list/yachts-for-sale/used/sail-monohulls/nicholson-32/249574
stray
stray

SA

325 posts

12 Jul 2020 10:59am
Select to expand quote
r13 said..

Ramona said..
Nicholson 32 is outside your sail requirements but is a better long keeler. Not many come up for sale, owners tend to hold on to them. Sell between 10 and 20 grand usually. Twice the interior room of a Compass 29. I'm not keen on the hard dodger on this one but it does have an Aries.
www.boatsonline.com.au/boats-for-sale/used/sailing-boats/camper-nicholson-32-mk-x/247471



This one?

yachthub.com/list/yachts-for-sale/used/sail-monohulls/nicholson-32/249574


This could be a good one if you're handy enough to pull the teak deck up and fill or glass over all the screw holes.
thats if its a glass deck underneath. If its plywood then that could be a big can of worms to be opening.
southace
southace

SA

4794 posts

12 Jul 2020 12:25pm
Honestly why are we getting a influx of people wanting to buy a cheap 70s small yacht and sail around the world? It's been done before, I couldn't think of anything worse than risking my life just to sail around the world in a small cheap boat. If it's really some dream you have had since childhood I would suggest you save you pennies and buy a good seaworthy 34ft + yacht and build up some experience before even thinking about circumnavigating the globe.
garymalmgren
garymalmgren

1365 posts

12 Jul 2020 11:04am
Honestly why are we getting a influx of people wanting to buy a cheap 70s small yacht and sail around the world?

Blame it on Youtube, Southy.

However. I think Covid might have pulled a lot of people up short.
No open ports of call makes for an extra boring circumnavigation.
OK. if you like non-stop, I guess.

gary
Andrew68
Andrew68

VIC

433 posts

12 Jul 2020 1:21pm
Select to expand quote
southace said..
Honestly why are we getting a influx of people wanting to buy a cheap 70s small yacht and sail around the world? It's been done before, I couldn't think of anything worse than risking my life just to sail around the world in a small cheap boat. If it's really some dream you have had since childhood I would suggest you save you pennies and buy a good seaworthy 34ft + yacht and build up some experience before even thinking about circumnavigating the globe.


I don't think Harks, has specifically said he is going to cruise the world, but I agree with your point that for making big ocean passages 30-40' is the go. Again there are so many costs that have nothing to do with the size of your boat, that getting into that category makes lots of sense.

A
Andrew68
Andrew68

VIC

433 posts

12 Jul 2020 1:24pm
Select to expand quote
garymalmgren said..
Honestly why are we getting a influx of people wanting to buy a cheap 70s small yacht and sail around the world?

Blame it on Youtube, Southy.

However. I think Covid might have pulled a lot of people up short.
No open ports of call makes for an extra boring circumnavigation.
OK. if you like non-stop, I guess.

gary


I guess Southy you are not a huge fan of this:

www.classglobe580.com

A
Achernar
Achernar

QLD

395 posts

12 Jul 2020 2:23pm
For a newby like Harks, (and I would not consider myself an "oldy", yet), I suggest the following
* get an smaller, cheaper boat now and live with it (not necessarily on it) for a couple of years, doing day-sails and weekenders. Look for the best condition boat you can get for your price range, keeping a few thousand in your pocket for the inevitable repairs and replacements.
* get your sailing experience up by actually sailing and taking courses - invest in your skills rather than your gear
* when you are ready and know what to look for, upgrade to a blue water cruiser
Ramona
Ramona

NSW

7737 posts

12 Jul 2020 5:59pm
Select to expand quote
r13 said..

Ramona said..
Nicholson 32 is outside your sail requirements but is a better long keeler. Not many come up for sale, owners tend to hold on to them. Sell between 10 and 20 grand usually. Twice the interior room of a Compass 29. I'm not keen on the hard dodger on this one but it does have an Aries.
www.boatsonline.com.au/boats-for-sale/used/sailing-boats/camper-nicholson-32-mk-x/247471



This one?

yachthub.com/list/yachts-for-sale/used/sail-monohulls/nicholson-32/249574


Nice example.
Harks
Harks

3 posts

12 Jul 2020 4:57pm
Oh...you guys mean sailings not coral reefs, drone footage and bikinis?

Considering the old/simple designs because of this:

www.atomvoyages.com/planning/good-old-boats-list.html

Even though the list has many full keel yacht around 30ft, 95% of'em are in the US which is why I am asking here.

And keep in mind, I'll be sailing solo 80% of the time, I figure anything over 30ft would be harder to short hand?

Is that the right verb...short hand?

Anyways.

I'm for a new skill, think sailings gonna be it.
southace
southace

SA

4794 posts

12 Jul 2020 9:16pm
Select to expand quote
Andrew68 said..

garymalmgren said..
Honestly why are we getting a influx of people wanting to buy a cheap 70s small yacht and sail around the world?

Blame it on Youtube, Southy.

However. I think Covid might have pulled a lot of people up short.
No open ports of call makes for an extra boring circumnavigation.
OK. if you like non-stop, I guess.

gary



I guess Southy you are not a huge fan of this:

www.classglobe580.com

A


That's a bit different to a Dunc 29 etc your looking at a 300k + global racer. Not the same as what was origionly posted.
Andrew68
Andrew68

VIC

433 posts

13 Jul 2020 12:40am
Select to expand quote
southace said..

Andrew68 said..


garymalmgren said..
Honestly why are we getting a influx of people wanting to buy a cheap 70s small yacht and sail around the world?

Blame it on Youtube, Southy.

However. I think Covid might have pulled a lot of people up short.
No open ports of call makes for an extra boring circumnavigation.
OK. if you like non-stop, I guess.

gary




I guess Southy you are not a huge fan of this:

www.classglobe580.com

A



That's a bit different to a Dunc 29 etc your looking at a 300k + global racer. Not the same as what was origionly posted.


The plans cost 300euros, and I think I heard Don say that the cost might be some thing like $50k to build, was no where near 300k.

A
Ramona
Ramona

NSW

7737 posts

13 Jul 2020 8:26am
Select to expand quote
Harks said..
Oh...you guys mean sailings not coral reefs, drone footage and bikinis?

Considering the old/simple designs because of this:

www.atomvoyages.com/planning/good-old-boats-list.html

Even though the list has many full keel yacht around 30ft, 95% of'em are in the US which is why I am asking here.

And keep in mind, I'll be sailing solo 80% of the time, I figure anything over 30ft would be harder to short hand?

Is that the right verb...short hand?

Anyways.

I'm for a new skill, think sailings gonna be it.


If it was my choice I would ignore that list and make an offer on the Rival 34 on eBay. It is larger than what your talking about and over your asking price but it is pretty much the ultimate long distance cruiser for solo sailors. It also is not long keeled but has a longish fin keel. Think SS34 with added seaworthiness! The boat is already fitted with a windvane self steering gear. I don't like the hard dodger but it may appeal to others. Correctly rigged this vessel would be no harder to handle than a 28 foot long keeler.

www.ebay.com.au/itm/RIVAL-34-YACHT/254632690064?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&_trksid=p2060353.m1438.l2649
Sydney88
Sydney88

NSW

108 posts

13 Jul 2020 10:23am
Not in the right price bracket but I had a compass 28 then got an Arends 33 considering you'll no doubt spend money doing it up to your liking you may as well save up and get something you can keep longer term and put your effort and money into getting that up to scratch rather than having to do it twice. If you could get a reasonable compass 28 for a good price closer to 10k +/- a few thousand depending on condition then I would consider it for a first boat to learn in for minimal cost I think it could easily do coastal passages safely. I love the Arends 33 but the Compass has a fond place in my heart as a solid simple boat that I always felt safe in and was easy to handle on my own. Personally I was never a fan of the Compass 29 especially with the wheel, tiller is much better for that size boat if you can get one.
Yara
Yara

NSW

1314 posts

13 Jul 2020 10:59am
Select to expand quote
Ramona said..


Harks said..
Oh...you guys mean sailings not coral reefs, drone footage and bikinis?

Considering the old/simple designs because of this:

www.atomvoyages.com/planning/good-old-boats-list.html

Even though the list has many full keel yacht around 30ft, 95% of'em are in the US which is why I am asking here.

And keep in mind, I'll be sailing solo 80% of the time, I figure anything over 30ft would be harder to short hand?

Is that the right verb...short hand?

Anyways.

I'm for a new skill, think sailings gonna be it.




If it was my choice I would ignore that list and make an offer on the Rival 34 on eBay. It is larger than what your talking about and over your asking price but it is pretty much the ultimate long distance cruiser for solo sailors. It also is not long keeled but has a longish fin keel. Think SS34 with added seaworthiness! The boat is already fitted with a windvane self steering gear. I don't like the hard dodger but it may appeal to others. Correctly rigged this vessel would be no harder to handle than a 28 foot long keeler.

www.ebay.com.au/itm/RIVAL-34-YACHT/254632690064?ssPageName=STRK%3AMEBIDX%3AIT&_trksid=p2060353.m1438.l2649



That is a classic quality British boat. I think Princess Anne had one.

Compass 28 is a good boat, however choose one with at least 10hp and preferably 12hp, and rigging less than 10 years old.
Achernar
Achernar

QLD

395 posts

13 Jul 2020 5:56pm
There is a nice library to browse through here.
bluewaterboats.org/
Achernar
Achernar

QLD

395 posts

13 Jul 2020 7:13pm
Select to expand quote
Achernar said..
There is a nice library to browse through here.
bluewaterboats.org/


Doing some browsing of my own, and found this gem of a quote for the Hardin 45 ...
"It isn't that fast for a boat, but she's pretty quick for a house".
Hevene
Hevene

NSW

24 posts

17 Nov 2020 1:54am
Select to expand quote
Sydney88 said..
Not in the right price bracket but I had a compass 28 then got an Arends 33 considering you'll no doubt spend money doing it up to your liking you may as well save up and get something you can keep longer term and put your effort and money into getting that up to scratch rather than having to do it twice. If you could get a reasonable compass 28 for a good price closer to 10k +/- a few thousand depending on condition then I would consider it for a first boat to learn in for minimal cost I think it could easily do coastal passages safely. I love the Arends 33 but the Compass has a fond place in my heart as a solid simple boat that I always felt safe in and was easy to handle on my own. Personally I was never a fan of the Compass 29 especially with the wheel, tiller is much better for that size boat if you can get one.


Sydney88, is the Arends 33 a solid fiberglass hull boat or is it cored?
FoolishBehaviour
FoolishBehaviour

NSW

51 posts

17 Nov 2020 6:34am
Harks, this one should tick all your boxes

yachthub.com/list/yachts-for-sale/used/sail-monohulls/currawong-30/254259
Ramona
Ramona

NSW

7737 posts

17 Nov 2020 8:40am
Select to expand quote
Warrina III said..
Harks, this one should tick all your boxes

yachthub.com/list/yachts-for-sale/used/sail-monohulls/currawong-30/254259


That's an excellent boat owned by a good looking old bloke but it does not meet the criteria of a slow boat with a long keel!
Yara
Yara

NSW

1314 posts

17 Nov 2020 10:43am
Select to expand quote
Ramona said..

Warrina III said..
Harks, this one should tick all your boxes

yachthub.com/list/yachts-for-sale/used/sail-monohulls/currawong-30/254259



That's an excellent boat owned by a good looking old bloke but it does not meet the criteria of a slow boat with a long keel!


A well maintained boat, designed by an engineering professor, what more could you want? If I was ten years younger I would sell my current boat (designed by a teenager), and go for this Currawong.
Zzzzzz
Zzzzzz

513 posts

17 Nov 2020 10:04am
Select to expand quote
southace said..
Honestly why are we getting a influx of people wanting to buy a cheap 70s small yacht and sail around the world? It's been done before, I couldn't think of anything worse than risking my life just to sail around the world in a small cheap boat. If it's really some dream you have had since childhood I would suggest you save you pennies and buy a good seaworthy 34ft + yacht and build up some experience before even thinking about circumnavigating the globe.


Really Southace ? Who are you to judge anyone on the year Or size of theIr boat That they are looking at?
The Compass 28 was designed by a person who put a lot of thought and know into his design of boat which over the years has proven itself countless times , not quite as much as the beautiful folkboat.It has its right of place in the sailing world , just as much as a yacht costing Millions of Dollars.
Just because it doesn't fit into your opinion of a yacht dose not give you the right to slang 70's boats , maybe you should put some of your own designs up on Seabreeze so we can have a look at your efforts .(Boats you have designed)
There are many reasons for someone to own a smaller older boat you don't have to be a beginner to own one.
Perry500
Perry500

NSW

66 posts

17 Nov 2020 1:33pm
Select to expand quote
Zzzzzz said..

southace said..
Honestly why are we getting a influx of people wanting to buy a cheap 70s small yacht and sail around the world? It's been done before, I couldn't think of anything worse than risking my life just to sail around the world in a small cheap boat. If it's really some dream you have had since childhood I would suggest you save you pennies and buy a good seaworthy 34ft + yacht and build up some experience before even thinking about circumnavigating the globe.



Really Southace ? Who are you to judge anyone on the year Or size of theIr boat That they are looking at?
The Compass 28 was designed by a person who put a lot of thought and know into his design of boat which over the years has proven itself countless times , not quite as much as the beautiful folkboat.It has its right of place in the sailing world , just as much as a yacht costing Millions of Dollars.
Just because it doesn't fit into your opinion of a yacht dose not give you the right to slang 70's boats , maybe you should put some of your own designs up on Seabreeze so we can have a look at your efforts .(Boats you have designed)
There are many reasons for someone to own a smaller older boat you don't have to be a beginner to own one.


Sorry, but have to agree with southace. The Compass 28 was never designed to cross oceans , but of course they could given the right weather. They lack displacement which is required when the going gets tough and not an overly strong build either. Currawong Ramona would get you safely anywhere, proven foul weather boat. A Folkboat would be more suited to an ocean crossing . Have a look for a Swanson 32 or 36, cracking yacht and cheap.
wongaga
wongaga

VIC

653 posts

17 Nov 2020 3:40pm
Select to expand quote

Sorry, but have to agree with southace. The Compass 28 was never designed to cross oceans , but of course they could given the right weather. They lack displacement which is required when the going gets tough and not an overly strong build either. Currawong Ramona would get you safely anywhere, proven foul weather boat. A Folkboat would be more suited to an ocean crossing . Have a look for a Swanson 32 or 36, cracking yacht and cheap.



Now I'm intrigued: whatever other shortcomings the C28 has, I've never heard them described as having a "not overly strong build", and as a long-term owner, I'm pretty impressed with the structure. I'd hate to circumnavigate in mine for various reasons, but not for lack of build strength.

As for lack of displacement, they're among the heavier yachts of their size/type, with SA/D of around 14 and ballast ratio of 55%. Mine always felt stable out in Bass Strait, but of course another couple of tonnes of momentum would have been even better to punch through waves. If you meant that any 28 footer, not just a C28, is too small for a circumnavigation I'd agree 100%.

Cheers, Graeme
End of posts
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site