Select to expand quote
Ilenart said..
To give some comparisons of Navionics to OpenCPN, a few months ago after leaving Middle Island near Esperance, I noticed our route was about to take us over a small island. I had created this route on OpenCPN and transferred it to the B&G plotter running Navionics. The island is at 34.62.33S 123.53.266E, is called Round Island and is a group of 4 islands. Navionics has a 7nm ring around it, which I assume you avoid. When I checked the OpenCPN chart none of the islands were on the map!
Later when we were approaching Daw Island I decided to do a comparison between the OpenCPN and Navionics charts. I found one rock I could clearly see about 50m wide and 20m high, plus 2 other rocks I could not see, plus a shallow spot 2nm to the east of Daw Island, all listed on Navionics. None of these rocks / shallows were detailed on OpenCPN.
We now always check any OpenCPN created routes with Navionics.
Ilenart
That is interesting. I have 3 different directories of CM93 on OpenCPN. They all show Round Island and the 3 adjacent Rocks. I show Round Island at 34 06' 10.8 and 123 53' 15.9. The updates dates for those files are 2010-01-04, 2000-07-06, 2009-05-11.
I cannot find Daw Island that you refer to. I would be interested in a Lat & Long
If you have multiple directories of C-Maps it is not always the newest revision that will give the most detail. There fore I will dis-able "Chart Quilting" and flip between directories to find the file with the most detail.
Mike