All is Lost

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
Ramona
Ramona
NSW
7752 posts
NSW, 7752 posts
18 Dec 2014 9:37am
Watched the Robert Redford movie "All is lost" on DVD last night. Now I knew what to expect, I had read pages of reviews from the Pommie yachting forums and was aware I would be fighting the urge to scream at the TV screen. But it was really bad! The acting and camera work was first class. There was pretty much everything wrong with his actions and reactions and I found myself disappointed when he did not drown at the end.
Could not use this film as a training tool and say do not do this because some info will stick. His immediate action should have been to shore up the hole, cushions/furniture on the inside, spare headsail hauled around the hull on the outside. This all happened in the first few minutes. Really the movie should have been about 30 minutes long. He spent more time shaving and eating than preserving his vessel.

And where did he find all that great weather!
Yara
Yara
NSW
1317 posts
NSW, 1317 posts
18 Dec 2014 4:34pm
Yes, it is a terrible movie. So many inaccuracies that it is just too hard for a sailor to "suspend the disbelief" which you are supposed to do in a movie. Starts at the first scene with sharks circling a liferaft. Yeh, they new Robert Redford was in there, and they just wanted to have a brush with fame.....
frant
frant
VIC
1230 posts
VIC, 1230 posts
18 Dec 2014 5:20pm
I was going to give Ramona a red thumb for bringing up this film again. Instead I write that I watched the Monty Python special the other day........ This is a dead parrot. The parrot is no more.
crustysailor
crustysailor
VIC
871 posts
VIC, 871 posts
18 Dec 2014 5:34pm
Ha you want a laugh?

'Windrider' was on C31 on the weekend, Nicole Kidman, Tom Burlinson, pastel blue wetsuits and mullets as far as the eye can see.

Filmed off WA, all of the long shots in the surf were in 30+ knots, then for the close up action, suddenly it was flat water and maybe 8-10 knots if that.

Even my kids picked it up..




Seamonkey_H2024
Seamonkey_H2024
VIC
344 posts
VIC, 344 posts
18 Dec 2014 5:50pm
I want to see a movie about a inexperienced sailor called Len who sails across the pacific in a cheap ferro yacht.
FreeRadical
FreeRadical
WA
855 posts
WA, 855 posts
18 Dec 2014 3:08pm
He did drown. Well that was my interpretation of the ending.
Ramona
Ramona
NSW
7752 posts
NSW, 7752 posts
18 Dec 2014 6:33pm
FreeRadical said..
He did drown. Well that was my interpretation of the ending.


No he swam up and a hand reached down.
Ramona
Ramona
NSW
7752 posts
NSW, 7752 posts
18 Dec 2014 6:51pm
Yara said..
Yes, it is a terrible movie. So many inaccuracies that it is just too hard for a sailor to "suspend the disbelief" which you are supposed to do in a movie. Starts at the first scene with sharks circling a liferaft. Yeh, they new Robert Redford was in there, and they just wanted to have a brush with fame.....


Actually that was the only real part of the movie. Once the dinghy has been inflated for a couple hours bait fish and other small critters gather. Under them and in the near vicinity will be a school of dolphin fish. Under that the other species in the food chain are various tunas hassling the dolphin fish, in the movie they had a barracuda! Below this are sharks. Every so often they chase each other about. Redford was pulling in a dolphin fish when the shark grabbed it.
LooseChange
LooseChange
NSW
2140 posts
NSW, 2140 posts
18 Dec 2014 7:39pm
SirJman said..
I want to see a movie about a inexperienced sailor called Len who sails across the pacific in a cheap ferro yacht.


Oh yes, that's a movie I want to see as well. I'm particularly keen to know if Fiji has deported him yet.
Datawiz
Datawiz
VIC
605 posts
VIC, 605 posts
18 Dec 2014 8:39pm
SirJman said..
I want to see a movie about a inexperienced sailor called Len who sails across the pacific in a cheap ferro yacht.


Me too!
DrRog
DrRog
NSW
608 posts
NSW, 608 posts
18 Dec 2014 11:55pm
The ending was ambiguous; I think it can be interpreted either way. But by the end (actually, within about 5 minutes) you're beyond caring.
FreeRadical
FreeRadical
WA
855 posts
WA, 855 posts
18 Dec 2014 10:29pm
Ramona said..

FreeRadical said..
He did drown. Well that was my interpretation of the ending.



No he swam up and a hand reached down.


I think that was the hand of god, or the devil, I'm not quite sure. Are they both right handed?
Sectorsteve
Sectorsteve
QLD
2195 posts
QLD, 2195 posts
19 Dec 2014 6:21am
watched abouy 10 minutes , couldnt watch anymore. horrible movie.
nswsailor
nswsailor
NSW
1458 posts
NSW, 1458 posts
19 Dec 2014 3:31pm
LooseChange said..
SirJman said..
I want to see a movie about a inexperienced sailor called Len who sails across the pacific in a cheap ferro yacht.


Oh yes, that's a movie I want to see as well. I'm particularly keen to know if Fiji has deported him yet.


Me too!
HG02
HG02
VIC
5814 posts
VIC, 5814 posts
19 Dec 2014 7:01pm
nswsailor said..

LooseChange said..

SirJman said..
I want to see a movie about a inexperienced sailor called Len who sails across the pacific in a cheap ferro yacht.



Oh yes, that's a movie I want to see as well. I'm particularly keen to know if Fiji has deported him yet.



Me too!


would not bother either
spongeblob
spongeblob
NSW
218 posts
NSW, 218 posts
19 Dec 2014 8:37pm
To be deported Len would have to get there first.
Charriot
Charriot
QLD
880 posts
QLD, 880 posts
19 Dec 2014 8:22pm
This is the concrete boats sank going to Gladstone.
Talked to the owner ..Len.. or perhaps his close relativ.
my admire for daring attemp to sail leaking junk of concrete




japie
japie
NSW
7146 posts
NSW, 7146 posts
1 Feb 2015 9:45pm
Wish I'd read this thread before hiring the bloody thing. My fourth entertainment movie since 2008.

Very disappointed!

Will stave off movies altogether now.
Jolene
Jolene
WA
1624 posts
WA, 1624 posts
1 Feb 2015 9:17pm
My wife has a video library in her shop and this movie is in it.
Allot of people want to talk about it as they know we have a boat. It doesn't take much explaining to convince people (non sailors) that the movie is Hollywood theatrical fiction. Its a bit like a submariner stomaching a sub movie,,,,,,,, Ping,Ping,Ping!
cisco
cisco
QLD
12365 posts
QLD, 12365 posts
2 Feb 2015 12:29am
japie said..
Wish I'd read this thread before hiring the bloody thing. My fourth entertainment movie since 2008.

Very disappointed!

Will stave off movies altogether now.


No don't do that mate. Get hold of "The Lucky Lady" with Gene Hackman, Burt Reynolds and Liza Minelli.

Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅