Hey bramber
further to topple, the size and shape of that board for kiting far outweighs the impact of fin changes most likely.
Just get some mid size, mid range quality fins and get going.
with the money you save, buy something like a 5'8 to 5'10, 20" wide, flattish fish or summery shape second hand for $150 or so. Get it fcs if possible if you want to use the same fins again (I prefer futures)
you will get far more variety and new learning experience out of comparing these 2 boards, then differing fin styles in the alternator.
then get new boards and repeat... and enjoy!