sir ROWDY said...simonmm said...
Short lines will have no appreciable affect on the turning speed of the kite or on the speed at which the kite flies through the window. The window will however be much smaller depending on the length of the lines and the kite will have a propensity to fly further forwards in the window. It can be difficult to get going with much shorter lines (ie sub 15m), as sining the kite produces less power than with longer lines. However once you get some board speed going it is not a whole lot different than with longer lines except you tend to point a bit further upwind. Kite loops tend to be a lot more radical/brutal on short lines as well. Quite a few people will ride 20m lines in the surf these days and personally I reckon that 15 or 17s aren't bad either if you like the small window for being able to flick the kite around without getting dragged down the line too far. I can't see too many advantage for freestyle. Some say that shorter lines enable you to fly a larger kite than you would otherwise in higher wind and I would also find this debatable. Kites can be quite squirrely in high winds on shorter lines and a looping kite on short lines can produce real painful surprises in strong wind.
It
will turn quicker because less line = less drag = less slack to pull in = faster response = quicker turning kite.
It
will fly through the window quicker because 4 or 5 times 7m lengths of line is actually alot of extra drag and will be noticable.
Why do you think it fly's further forward in the window on shorter lines...
Also why do you think it goes up wind better...
Because it has less drag to fly faster through the window/ further forward into the wind.
You
will be able to fly a kite size or 2 bigger because once again it can fly further forward in the window effectivley catching less of the wind than what it would if it was on longer lines sitting deeper in the window. It can be very on off kinda kiting if the wind is gusty though.
By the sounds of things I'm not sure whether you have actually tried short lines before or maybe you did it one time and forgot what it was like.
Your theories are pretty funny. I am sure you believe you are right and are not much interested in hearing anything that might be different from your preconcieved ideas, but for the benefit of other out there asking the question:
1. The speed at which a kite turns is dictated by a differential in wing pressure between either side of the canopy. Line length will not have an appreciable effect. It is quite common for people to confuse the feel of flying with shorter lines to that of flying a faster turning kite.
2. You do the math, but a 0.28cm squared increase in surface area will not have a profound effect on the flying speed of the kite. The effect of having a much smaller window to work with would be much more noticable that a miniscule increase in the cross section of the kite.
3. The the effect of the kite flying marginally further forwards will have minimal distinction compared to pulling in more depower on a kite on longer lines. Sure you may get by on a size larger with short lines, but my point is that when things go wrong mistakes will be equally unforgiving with a kite on either long or short lines. The larger power stroke generated by a kite on longer lines I think is fairly offset by the twitchy nature of a kite with short lines in strong wind.
I have spent a lot of time flying with short lines and just think that in general it is easy to confuse the very significant impact of having a smaller window with the relatively small increases in flying or turning speed.