Snapped bar

> 10 years ago
Reply
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
geordieboy
geordieboy
WA
224 posts
WA, 224 posts
23 Feb 2015 9:54am




Hi was out at mullas blowing 22/23 knots on my core Gt. 9m It's about 5-6 years old ? Not sure when heading back in and my bar snapped clean in two
Had to do my first self rescue has anybody had this problem with core bars


seanhogan
seanhogan
QLD
3424 posts
QLD, 3424 posts
23 Feb 2015 12:37pm
again... at least it's not in the windsurf section...
jusavina
jusavina
QLD
1504 posts
QLD, 1504 posts
23 Feb 2015 12:47pm
That's not even carbon fibre Bro!
Sailhack
Sailhack
VIC
5000 posts
VIC, 5000 posts
23 Feb 2015 2:22pm
Could it be a case of too much downhaul in this instance?
pweedas
pweedas
WA
4642 posts
WA, 4642 posts
23 Feb 2015 11:26am
They come with a safety warning,.. "NOT FOR USE BY PEOPLE OVER 150KG"
Macroscien
Macroscien
QLD
6809 posts
QLD, 6809 posts
23 Feb 2015 2:17pm
Keep it . Looks like you could do two walking sticks of those things.
oldjenkins
oldjenkins
WA
77 posts
WA, 77 posts
23 Feb 2015 9:19pm
Had this happen to a Naish bar at Southgates in Gero. The old days of flying a stunt kite on the separate handles worked a treat. Managed to fly the kite and get into the beach OK. Naish replaced the bar but Kym from Gero S&S reckoned that they wouldn't believe a bar had broken. apparently unheard of they claim. Bar was only 12 months old.....
Nice to know I'm not so special
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
23 Feb 2015 9:29pm
OMG

Only lasted 5 yrs

Must post "have others had same problem"


reallly???!!!!
kitebt
kitebt
NSW
325 posts
NSW, 325 posts
24 Feb 2015 3:16am
Bar Price $700.00

Average number of sessions per year = 50 (very conservative)

5 years = 250 sessions

$700.00/250 sessions

$2.80 a session

Pretty good return on investment for that bar. Just get a new one. It's 5 years old that's a pretty good run.


ActionSportsWA
ActionSportsWA
WA
1005 posts
WA, 1005 posts
24 Feb 2015 9:02am
We are the Core dealer for WA
We have seen this happen twice, but in both of those instances it was in massively overpowered situations where the rider had slack lined/stalled the kite, became unhooked, the kite powered back up and the very heavy 2008/2009 chicken loop assembly on the old core bar smashed into the centre hole.
In both these instances Core replaced the bar, they were however within the warranty period for one bar and just outside for the other.
We do have a naked Esp bar in stock, so you can swop all of the fittings centre line assembly the bars are about $150-175 AUD (can't remember as its 8am and I'm at home) but it will take you a while to swop all the fittings over especially the centre lines (couple of hours for the average person).
We have sensor bar 2's in stock which are compatable at about $550.
Toddy
skywalker3d
skywalker3d
VIC
228 posts
VIC, 228 posts
24 Feb 2015 1:10pm
I Have only been kiting 2 years and would not imagine getting 5 years out of my gear. As i use it every weekend. I was thinking 3 years and throw it in the bin??
snalberski
snalberski
WA
858 posts
WA, 858 posts
24 Feb 2015 11:03am
How about this? $62Aud. Seems to be just the same as the Core



MDSXR6T
MDSXR6T
WA
1019 posts
WA, 1019 posts
24 Feb 2015 4:41pm
I need a small kite for high the high 20's low 30's day's and there's a 9m core in the FS section with an ESP bar.

Keen to go halves (it's advertised at $400 but has been for sale for ages with a professional repair so maybe $250 i think) as i don't need the bar?
Lambie
Lambie
QLD
742 posts
QLD, 742 posts
24 Feb 2015 7:42pm
Get an all alloy bar like the F-One Monolith bar and Id be very surprised if you couldn't use it for 10 or more years - you wont break it through normal use and abuse - now the Airlight bar of the Bandit 4's is a different beast - wouldn't touch one of them (bad, bad corrosion) but the Bandit 5 bars were anodised so no corrosion and again a full aluminium bar.

I snapped a Bandit 3 bar once - carbon fibre/glass bar - nice to use but I simply stuffed up - extreme load - my fault!

Geordieboy - for your bar to break - glass resin - it almost must have had some severe impact to start a crack in its past life ?? And then ongoing flex stress would have been slowly weakening it to the point of failure ?? That said I have no experience with Core bars which is what you were asking about but apparently no one here rides core kites??

I would hope, that despite the economic analysis outlined above, that a bar should outlast the kite and maybe 2 !!
mazdon
mazdon
1199 posts
1199 posts
24 Feb 2015 5:54pm
i thought that was going to be a "keen to go halves in the bar" joke for sure
flyingcab
flyingcab
VIC
942 posts
VIC, 942 posts
24 Feb 2015 11:02pm
Mark _australia said..
OMG

Only lasted 5 yrs

Must post "have others had same problem"


reallly???!!!!

what is wrong with you... you don't own these forums!
ikw777
ikw777
QLD
2995 posts
QLD, 2995 posts
24 Feb 2015 11:43pm
Hang on! You guys pay $700 for a bar!!!
Mark _australia
Mark _australia
WA
23647 posts
WA, 23647 posts
24 Feb 2015 10:04pm
flyingcab said..

Mark _australia said..
OMG

Only lasted 5 yrs

Must post "have others had same problem"


reallly???!!!!


what is wrong with you... you don't own these forums!


Well - no I don't

However I think (and feel free to correct me if I ma wrong) that 5yrs may be an acceptable lifespan for a bar. It is subject to a lot of stress. EG: windsurf booms also last about that long. Being longer, they are possibly subject to even more bending moment, but I digress....

My point is, after 5 yrs it is a bit rough to post that it broke and "has this happened to anyone else....?" It sounds like you are dissing the product.

If it was 6mths, yes. 5yrs hmmmmmm......


Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site 😭
Or... let us know if a problem, so we can tweak! 😅