snalberski said..
Getting solid unbiased opinions is hard to find because mostly instructors will be connected to retail shops, retail shops have their product range agenda and everyone including instructors, shops, locals at the beach, forum posters and me have their own preferences, logic and ideas. Even if you found two experienced kiters with no agenda their opinions and advice would likely be different
Shops have name and reputations. Do you really think they will try to sell you some crap just because they need to get rid of it?
Most of the shops don't even stock the C shapes anymore and that leaves the customers with a broad choice of wave, freeride, hybrid-C that are all beginner friendly.
People who don't know what to buy should trust a shop more than the advice given by people like you. People in shops have in experience.
Of course they have an agenda but is that an issue? They have relationships with the brands they represent which is passed onto their client and known as "customer service".
Seriously Snalberski, not long ago (and it still might be the case) you were riding with a reel leash because you were lacking basic skills and riding way overpowered all the time so please keep the silly advice for yourself and let the pros do their jobs.