Hi guys,
I think that although there is some truth in what you say, quality modern boards are a far cry from what we were buying years ago.
The first boards were foam inner with timber panels under the heel areas, glass and some carbon and were very stiff, heavy and broke easily. Mostly no bottom shape, badly foiled fins and uncomfortable lousy footstraps and literally 5mm thick foot grip (you couldn't even call pads
The modern boards do have progressive flex and depending upon what you are after, there are many good boards to choose from to suit every style. I agree that there are some nasty Chinese pop outs with poor flex design and even at 800 they are way overpriced.
A quality board like the 09 Airush FS, 09 North Jaimie Pro for general freestyle riding or on the 09 North Mallory for New school/wake are just wicked. They have good flex where you need it, are strong and comfortable to ride in. Although they are a lot of money, they will last you for years if you look after them. I loop mine pretty hard and haven't managed to break a board in quite a while. Most quality companies will warranty a broken board so really thats what you are buying, a nice ride and peace of mind.
Rowdy, you get better edging due to the locked angle at the ankle from the bindings. Most boards will edge better in boots, especially if they are made for boots like the Mallory.
I love the new boards, they advance your riding so much if you buy the board that most suits the way you want to ride. Buy the wrong board and you have to "put up with it" and try and convince yourself that what you parted with a grand for, is a quality ride. Soon as you jump on something quality, you'll know you made a mistake.
Good winds,