myscreenname said..
Alexander the Great
Catherine the Great
Peter the Great
Frederick the Great
Cyrus the Great
Ramesses the Great
Herod the Great
Charlemagne (Charles the Great)
Theodoric the Great
Justinian the Great
Canute the Great
Suleiman the Great (Suleiman the Magnificent)
Gustavus Adolphus the Great
Casimir the Great
Otto the Great
Pompey the Great
Llywelyn the Great
Khosrow the Great
Sasanian Theodosius the Great
Mithridates the Great
Sejong the Great
Basil the Great
Gregory the Great
Leo the Great
Mithridates the Great
Harsha the Great
Yury the Great
Sancho the Great
Nader Shah the Great
meh. Not so sure myscreenname.
Half that list are charlatans, self-proclaimed or were referred to as "the great' out of fear or politics, not out of broad-based respect and admiration. If that is the metric you'd include just about everyone who ever lived.
I was referring to people who earnt the title by contempories who weren't their promoters and deserved the title, not simply those who claimed the title.
If you run on that basis we'd have to accept it is indeed President Trump the Greatest, and clearly that isn't a reasonable methodology of assessment. It would be like having 'knob-cheese', 'riff-raff' telling the seabreeze.com.au community who should be remembered as 'The Great'. That would be 'misinformation'.
Maybe Alexander and Herod - but I'd also like to narrow the parameters down to exclude those who lived in pre-history, where the records become more like fables and religous texts than true historical records.
Catherine the Great is certainly referred by the title, but it was given to her long after her death by historians, not by those she ruled over.
Llywelyn might be a viable contender, I forget about that great celtic leader. Heralded as 'the great' by contempories in England I believe, so meets the criteria.
But Canute ? Show me anyone who called him Canute the Great, other than perhaps himself or his closest biased supporters and history writers trying to sell books in the modern era ?