Select to expand quote
FormulaNova said..
I have been watching The Walking Dead after buying the seasons on Google Play.
It is so frustrating! For those that watch it, do you find it as frustrating!
Nope. I love it.
Select to expand quote
FormulaNova said..When you are surrounded by a world full of dangerous zombies that can kill you with a bite, what do you do? Protect yourself? No, you sit around in deck chairs talking about your feelings.
Yes, but only AFTER you've killed them and cleared the area, at least for a few hours or days if you're lucky. I would do the same, to try and get a normal sense of life back. Hell, if there was a book lying about I might try and read it too! Karl does that exactly on one episode.
Select to expand quote
FormulaNova said..You are in a prison with walls and cell blocks. Do you kill all the zombies and reinforce the walls? No, you sit around and talk about your feelings.
That's not what happened. As soon as they found the prison and then cleared the Zombies, then they started to sit down and talk about feelings, etc. I do agree their banter is sometimes over the top and too relaxed, but again I would have done the same for the reason I said above.
Select to expand quote
Your compound is attracting more and more zombies, what do you do? Do you kill them methodically to remove the threat? No, you let them build up in such numbers where they push down the fences at which time you panic.(While talking about your feelings)
Again, that's not what happened. Yes the Zombies tore down the walls, but that's because they had a sudden influx of them that appeared out of no where. They did try and distract the zombies by sacrificing their pig sty to them, but it was a waste and to no avail. The zombie numbers was just too much. They even tried to kill them on the fence line, but realised that by killing them on the fence, the zombies that were still "alive" could climb over the dead ones. So they gave up on the fence eventually.
You must be watching a French version of the show, cause they did everything they could to stop the influx. Again I too would have done the same.
Select to expand quote
FormulaNova said..When you go outside into the world full of zombies, do you arm yourselves? Do you carry knives and guns with you at all times? No, you put the guns in the boot, and don't worry about knives unless you happen to have one handy.
Boy you must have started watching the show half way between Season 3, because they soon discovered (Season 1 I think even), that using up their short supply of bullets was useless. That is why they started getting good at using knifes, sticks, anything with a point or an edge to penetrate into the rotten brain!
Select to expand quote
FormulaNova said..When going on a mission to get supplies, do you take a well armed group and approach it methodically? No, you take 2 people, with minimal weapons, and spread out.
Again, I would do the same. Two people back to back can fight off a large number of Zombies, with good weapons other than a gun, that attracts them anyway due to the loud bangs. I think in Season 4 episode 12, they do exactly that and kill off heaps of them. But of course it depends on the skill level you're at with regards to killing without hesitation and without regret or emotion. Two people ruthless enough to survive can survive.
Select to expand quote
FormulaNova said..You are involved in a gun fight and there are shots all around you, as well as hundreds of deadly zombies. Your son has just shot two zombies that are about to get you. There are many more around. What do you do? Run away with your son? No, you hug him, and talk about your feelings.
LOL. Your hypothesis on these episodes is making me laugh. Yes! Why waste precious energy and time killing off zombies in the immediate vicinity if you could just kill those that you need to, to get out of the way, and hell why not have a chat about life in general considering you can walk or even run faster than any zombie? Again, it comes down to survival and only using defences and attacks when absolutely necessary.
Select to expand quote
You are in a prison with sick people, conveniently with hundreds of lockable cells. When the people die they turn into zombies and are a threat. What do you do? Lock them in their cells until they are better or die? No, you let them roam around the cell block and kill the others until you realise what has happened.
No. Again, that is NOT what happened. The sick kid that fell due to the flu disease was the first zombie and he attacked others in the cells because no one knew what happened to him and the attacks were coming from the inside of the prison whilst Karl and others were outside dealing with other matters. No one could have stopped the inside attacks from people that have succumbed to the "pig disease" that later turned them all to zombies. In the end, the core group of survivors from Season 1 and 2 were the only ones left. So all that nicety of Ric saving the people from the commune was a waste of time.
If anything about the show I hate, is Rick's inconsistencies with his decisions to protect the group. One day he's all lovey and accepting members from anywhere, and the next he's resisting new members, even killing them or not killing those that are more of a threat to the entire group.
Select to expand quote
FormulaNova said..You have just been attacked by a rival group and survived, but their leader is still at large? What do you do? reinforce your compound and put sentries out? No, you dig holes in the garden and wait for the bad guy to show up and shoot you. (While talking about your feelings).
"where's Karl?", "Karl", "Karl, where's Karl!".
This is the only part of your comments that I agree with. Rick should have killed the Governor on the spot when he had the chance with the gun under the table (or was it the other way around?). Well he had a chance anyway to kill him and for the others on the outside to have turned quickly and kill off the other losers. Karl later in Season 4 says the same thing to his dad and is about to kill him thinking he turned. I still think he should have!

Personally, I love this show and Season 3 was the best so far. Full of action, drama and suspense.
Well written.